Money: reserve, repair or replace, running cost
Three calculators: what to set aside a year for one component, whether repairing or replacing costs less per year, and what two appliances cost to run over their lives. All arithmetic, with every figure it rests on named.
Three boxes, all arithmetic. Each one lists the figures it rests on underneath it, and none of them has a cost figure built in: every dollar amount is one you supply, from a local quote or a bill.
1. The annual reserve, one component at a time
Answers: what to set aside a year for one component, how many years it has left on the published figure, and what you would have to find each year to be ready if you are starting late. Run it once per row on your systems sheet and copy each annual figure into that row's Annual set-aside column, which the printed house file sums. Used in What upkeep costs and What wears out and when.
Assumptions behind the numbers
- Straight-line reserving, which is the replacement cost divided by the expected life, is this manual's arithmetic and not a published method. Nobody we could cite publishes a household reserving formula.
- The service life is whichever publisher you recorded, usually InterNACHI's chart, which carries no publication date and no methodology. The service life table states that on every row.
- The replacement cost is your own local quote or a figure you name. This manual ships no built-in cost figures, because we did not find a dated, citable national cost set worth building on, and contractor marketing surveys do not qualify.
- No inflation and no interest are modeled. The figure is in today's dollars and assumes the money sits still.
- The catch-up figure divides what is left to find by the years remaining, with one year as the floor, so a component already at or past its published life shows the whole remaining balance.
2. Repair or replace
Answers: what repairing costs per year of life it buys, against what replacing costs per year of the replacement's life. Used in Choosing and keeping appliances and Heating, cooling and hot water. The number that decides it is the extra years, and that number comes from the technician, so ask for it in writing with the repair quote.
Assumptions behind the numbers
- The common rule that you replace when a repair costs more than half a new one is folklore, with no published basis we found, and this box does not use it. It compares two prices while ignoring how long each one lasts, which is the whole question.
- Extra years is an estimate, usually the technician's, so the result inherits that uncertainty and the box says which number settles it.
- The box does not include running cost. Where the old machine is substantially less efficient, add the difference from box 3 below.
- The box does not include what a failure would cost. A machine over a finished ceiling or in a finished basement is the sudden-and-wet case in What wears out and when, and that belongs in the decision separately.
- Parts availability is not modeled. A repair needing a part nobody stocks is not a repair with an uncertain cost; it is not a repair.
3. Appliance running cost, two models compared
Answers: what each model costs to run in a year and over its life at your electricity rate, and what the two come to with their purchase prices included. Used in Choosing and keeping appliances. Take the kilowatt hour figures off the yellow EnergyGuide labels, and take your rate from a bill as the total charge divided by the kilowatt hours used, which includes delivery and fixed charges.
Assumptions behind the numbers
- The kilowatt hour figure comes from the yellow label, which 16 CFR part 305 defines as an estimate determined by a test procedure. It is not a bill and it is not a prediction of your household's use.
- The rate is yours, from a bill. The label's own dollar figure prices the same kilowatt hours at a national energy figure instead, which is why this box ignores it.
- No rate escalation is modeled. The arithmetic holds today's rate for the whole period.
- Electricity only. A gas appliance's running cost needs a gas rate in a different unit and is outside this box.
- The expected life is yours to choose. ENERGY STAR uses a 12-year lifetime in its refrigerator figures, which is one defensible choice among several; the service life table has the published figures by class.
All three boxes perform arithmetic on estimates, and the output inherits every assumption underneath it. A reserve figure rests on an estimated cost and a published service life from a chart with no methodology. A repair-or-replace result rests on somebody's guess about extra years. A lifetime running cost rests on a test result and an unchanging rate. None of them tells you what will happen; they tell you what follows from the numbers you entered, which is worth a great deal and is not the same thing. Write the assumptions into the row on your sheet beside the answer.
A worked pass
Ray and Diane Okonkwo, the 1958 ranch outside Dayton, ran box 1 four times, once per row on their systems sheet, using four local quotes they collected in one afternoon and InterNACHI's published figures from the service life table. They copied each annual figure into the Annual set-aside column and let the printed house file sum them.
What they wrote beside the total, in one sentence: that the reserve is more than they can set aside, that the shortfall comes out of tier 3, and that they are not reducing the reserve figure to match the money. The roof row is the weakest of the four, because its age is still unknown pending a permit search, so its catch-up figure is the one they treat with the most suspicion.
They have not run box 2 or box 3 yet. Box 2 waits for something to break; box 3 waits for a label to read. Both are here for the day the question arrives, which is a bad day to be working out a method.