What home upkeep actually costs, and what to set aside
The published national spending figures, the two rules of thumb that have no published basis, and a reserve built from your own components instead of from either.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. What the published figures actually say
- 2. The 1 percent rule, named
- 3. A reserve built from your own components
- 4. Maintenance, repairs and improvements
- 5. The gap, and which tier it comes out of
- 6. What insurance does and does not do
- 7. See it
- 8. Practice
- 9. Your house
- 10. Check your work
- 11. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
At minimum, price your systems rows, run one reserve figure, and write the gap down. The rules-of-thumb comparison, the basis records and the report's own caveats are Go deeper.
- Put a replacement cost beside each row on your systems sheet, from a local quote or a published figure, and say in the row which it was (building a reserve).
- Run the reserve calculator for each row and copy the annual figure into the Annual set-aside column.
- Write the annual total and what you can actually set aside on the log (the gap).
- If there is a gap, write which tier it comes out of, in a sentence, on the same sheet.
Minimum time: about an hour, plus whatever the quotes take. Done when: one annual reserve figure and one sentence naming the tier the shortfall comes from are written down.
1. What the published figures actually say Understand
There is less published about what home maintenance costs than most people expect, and a great deal of confident advice about it. The best national figures we found come from Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies, whose Improving America's Housing report is built on the American Housing Survey and the Center's own modeling, and is published every two years.
Here is what the 2025 edition reports, with the year attached to every number, because these are measurements of particular years rather than rules:
| Figure | Year | What it counts |
|---|---|---|
| 75 percent of owners spent something on maintenance, and the number rose from 60 million to 65 million households | 2019 to 2023 | The share spending anything, which held steady while the count grew |
| Average per owner maintenance spending reached a new high of $1,200 | 2023 | Maintenance, averaged across owners |
| Average per owner improvement spending was almost $4,700 | 2023 | Improvements, which are a different category (see section 4) |
| Maintenance spending on pre-1980 homes ran 76 percent higher than on homes built since 2010; improvements 24 percent higher | 2023 | The age effect, in what owners actually spent |
| Owners aged 65 and over went from an inflation-adjusted $1,800 to $3,800 in average per owner spending | 2003 to 2023 | A twenty-year shift in who is spending |
| Median age of the housing stock: 44 years | 2023 | Context for all of the above |
| The remodeling market peaked at $611 billion and is expected to remain near $600 billion through 2025 | 2022 to 2025 | The whole market, for scale |
What these are Averages of what people spent. Not a budget, not a requirement and not a forecast for your house. An average across 65 million households includes the year somebody replaced nothing and the year somebody replaced a roof, and your own year will be one or the other rather than the average of them.
What they are good for is calibration. If your own reserve arithmetic produces a figure near $1,200 a year on a newer house, that is unsurprising. If it produces $400, it is probably missing rows. If it produces $6,000 on a 1920s house with original everything, that is not evidence that the arithmetic is wrong.
2. The 1 percent rule, named
Two rules of thumb circulate constantly: set aside 1 percent of the home's value a year, and set aside a dollar per square foot a year. You will meet both, usually without a source.
We looked for a published basis for either and did not find one. No agency, no extension service, no federal publication and no research report we fetched gives either figure or anything it could be derived from. That does not make them wrong. It makes them folklore: advice that circulates on its own authority, and this manual labels it as such rather than repeating it or quietly omitting it.
Omitting it is the worse option, because a reader who does not meet it here will meet it somewhere else without the label. So here is what the two rules produce, side by side with the published average, for this manual's fictional cases:
| House | 1 percent of value | A dollar a square foot | The 2023 published average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Okonkwo: 1958 ranch, 1,450 sq ft, Dayton | Depends entirely on the market, and moves with it | $1,450 | $1,200 across all owners; the pre-1980 figure runs 76 percent higher |
| Reyes: 1996 two-story, Austin | A much larger number for the same house in a hotter market | Scales with size, not with what is in it | Same $1,200 average, with a newer-home effect downward |
| Baptiste: 1920s farmhouse, Vermont | A small number, because rural value is low | A small number, because the house is small | The pre-1980 figure, which is where she actually sits |
Look at the last row. The 1 percent rule gives Odette Baptiste the smallest reserve of the three, for a hundred-year-old house with an oil boiler, a well and a septic system. That is the rules' structural problem: neither of them knows what is in the house. Market value measures location. Square footage measures size. Upkeep is driven by components, their ages and their replacement costs, which is what the next section builds from instead.
A defensible use If you want a sanity check rather than a budget, the rules are not harmful as a floor: a reserve far below a dollar a square foot on an older house is probably missing rows. Used that way they are a prompt to go back to the sheet, which is a reasonable job for a number with no source.
3. A reserve built from your own components
The arithmetic is one line, repeated per component:
Annual set-aside = replacement cost divided by expected service life.
Sum the column and you have a figure that knows what is in your house. The reserve calculator does it, and also gives you the catch-up figure, which is what is left to find divided by the years remaining, for a component you are starting late on.
Three things the box needs, and what each one is worth:
- The replacement cost. Your own local quote is best. A published figure is acceptable if you say in the row that it is one. This manual ships no built-in cost figures, deliberately: the dated, citable, national cost sets we looked for do not exist in a form worth building on, and the figures that circulate come from contractor marketing surveys, which are not a source.
- The expected service life. From the service life table, with the publisher named, or from your own evidence where it disagrees. What wears out and when covers both.
- The age now. From the data plate or the sticker, or the word unknown, in which case you are reserving against an unknown remaining life and the catch-up figure is the honest number to use.
A reserve figure is arithmetic performed on estimates. The cost is an estimate, the service life is a published estimate from a trade association, and the age is sometimes an assumption. None of that makes it useless; a number built from your own components and labeled as an estimate is a far better planning object than a percentage of a market value. But the figure inherits every assumption underneath it, and so does any decision taken from it. Write the assumptions in the row.
What the reserve does It does not reduce what the house costs. It moves a cost from unpredictable to predictable, which is the only general claim this manual makes about upkeep. A roof replaced from a fund you built over twelve years costs the same as a roof replaced from a loan in a bad week. What differs is the number of decisions you make under pressure.
4. Maintenance, repairs and improvements
Three categories that get used interchangeably and should not be, because they behave differently in planning and differently in tax.
| Category | What it is | In your plan |
|---|---|---|
| Maintenance | Keeping something working as it is: filters, service visits, clearing gutters, flushing a tank | Recurring, small, calendar-driven. The whole of Your own calendar |
| Repair | Putting something back to working order after it stopped | Unpredictable in timing; this is what the emergency side of your money is for |
| Improvement | Adding something, or replacing something with something better | Optional and usually larger. Not what the reserve is for |
The line between a repair and an improvement is genuinely blurry, and it has a consequence beyond planning. IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home, draws a distinction that matters to an owner keeping records: the cost of improvements adds to the home's basis, while repairs that merely maintain the home do not. An owner who keeps invoices sorted into the two categories has done something useful for a future sale as well as for a future plan.
Ask the authority That is the whole of what this manual says about tax. Which side of the line a particular job falls on, how basis works in your situation, and what records are adequate are questions for a tax professional and for the publication itself. Nothing here is tax advice.
The practical habit is small: when you file an invoice, write M, R or I on it. It takes a second and it is the kind of thing nobody reconstructs later.
5. The gap, and which tier it comes out of
For most households the reserve figure is larger than what can be set aside. That is the normal result, and the chapter's real work is what you do with it.
The wrong answer is to adjust the reserve downward until it matches the money, because that produces a number that is no longer about the house. The right answer is to leave the reserve honest and decide, in writing, where the shortfall lands.
Work down the tiers from the bottom:
- Tier 5 goes first, and should already have gone. Cosmetics are the one tier you can set aside for a year with no consequence beyond looking at it.
- Tier 4 next, with its own arithmetic. Deferring tier 4 costs the running total: the duct sealing you do not do keeps costing whatever it was costing. ENERGY STAR's figure of up to 20 percent efficiency improvement from sealing and insulating ducts, and up to 10 percent on annual energy bills from sealing and insulating, are the published bounds to weigh that against. Some tier 4 rows are cheap enough that deferring them is a false economy; others are capital projects.
- Tier 3 is where a shortfall actually hurts, and where the decision should be explicit: which component are you choosing to meet with a loan or a credit card rather than a fund? Name it. That sentence is the most useful one on the sheet.
- Tier 1 and tier 2 do not come out. If the arithmetic says they have to, the conversation is a different one: a smaller tier 1 fix that buys time, a payment plan with a contractor, or an assistance program. Some utilities, states and nonprofits run weatherization and repair assistance programs, and the place to ask is your state or local housing or energy office.
Write the result as a sentence on the log: "Reserve says $2,400 a year; we can do $1,200; the shortfall comes out of tier 3, specifically the air conditioner, which we will meet with a loan if it fails before 2029." That is a plan. "We will see" is not.
6. What insurance does and does not do
Insurance is the other half of how a household meets a large house cost, and the division between it and the reserve is clean in principle: a policy generally covers sudden and accidental damage, not wear. A roof blown off is one thing; a roof worn out is another.
What is published and worth knowing is the shape of the claims. The Insurance Information Institute, crediting ISO, reports for 2018 to 2022, by claims per 100 insured house years and average claim size:
| Cause | Claims per 100 insured house years | Average claim |
|---|---|---|
| Wind and hail | 2.80 | $14,747 |
| Water damage and freezing | 1.50 | $15,400 |
| All other property damage | 0.88 | Not stated in the figures we read |
| Fire and lightning | 0.23 | $88,170 |
| Theft | 0.12 | $5,524 |
III also reports that in 2023, 5.3 percent of insured homes had a claim, that property damage including theft was 97.3 percent of homeowners claims, and that by share of incurred losses in 2023 wind and hail was 42.5 percent, water damage and freezing 22.6 percent and fire and lightning 21.2 percent.
Two things follow for a planner. Water is the category you can most affect, which is the argument in The priority rule. And fire is the category where the claim size tells you why tier 2 is tier 2: it happens rarely and when it happens the number is in a different order of magnitude.
Your own policy is the only authority on your own coverage, including deductibles, exclusions, and how it treats damage that follows from a maintenance failure. This manual states nothing about what is covered. If a tier 1 row in your house looks like it could become a claim, have that conversation with your insurer before rather than after.
The two rules of thumb, worked for each case
Section 2 shows the structure of the problem; here is the diagnosis. A dollar a square foot moves with size and ignores age, fuel type, climate, well and septic, and what is actually installed. One percent of value moves with the local market, which means the same physical house carries a reserve several times larger in an expensive metro than in a rural county, for identical components. In the fictional cases, Odette Baptiste's 1920s Vermont farmhouse comes out lowest on both rules and highest on the component arithmetic, because she has an oil boiler, a well, a septic system and a hundred-year-old building. Where the two rules are useful is as a floor: if your component arithmetic lands well below both on an older house, go back and look for the rows you left out.
Why two houses are not comparable
A 1920s farmhouse with a well and a septic system has three major systems a 2015 apartment does not have, and its envelope is a different kind of object. Comparing their reserves, or their owners' spending, tells you about the buildings rather than about the owners. The same applies to comparing your own figure with a friend's.
Home warranties and service contracts
These come up constantly in the same conversation as a reserve, and they are not the same thing. FTC's position is that home warranties are really service contracts, that unlike builder warranties or warranties included with products they cost extra, and that they may duplicate coverage you already have. Hiring help works through FTC's four questions in full.
Keeping records for basis
IRS Publication 523 is the reference for what adds to a home's basis when it is sold. The useful habit is the filing one described in section 4: mark each invoice M, R or I as it arrives, and keep the I pile. What counts, and how it works in your situation, is a question for a tax professional.
The Harvard report's own caveats
The Joint Center's figures come from the American Housing Survey and from the Center's own modeling, and the report describes its methods. Two things to keep in mind when quoting it: the categories are defined by the survey rather than by how a householder thinks about a job, and the improvement and maintenance split follows those definitions. Averages across tens of millions of households also hide enormous variation, which is why this manual uses them for calibration and not as a budget.
7. See it See it
Ray and Diane Okonkwo, the 1958 ranch outside Dayton, working from the four systems rows they dated in What wears out and when. Costs are their own local quotes except where noted.
| Component | Replacement cost | Service life used | Annual set-aside |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gas furnace | Quoted locally, with the air conditioner | InterNACHI's figure | Cost divided by life |
| Central air conditioner | Quoted locally, as a pair | InterNACHI's figure | Cost divided by life |
| Gas tank water heater | Quoted locally | InterNACHI's figure | Cost divided by life |
| Asphalt shingle roof | Quoted locally | InterNACHI's figure | Cost divided by life |
Known: three install dates from labels, and four local quotes they asked for by telephone in one afternoon.
Assumed, and the assumptions are named in each row: the roof's age, which is still unknown pending the permit search, so its catch-up figure is computed against an assumed end of life rather than a known remaining life. The service lives are InterNACHI's, from a chart with no publication date and no methodology.
Still open, with who settles each: whether the furnace and air conditioner go together or separately, which changes the quote and which the heating technician can advise on at the annual service; and the roof's age, which the building department settles.
What they wrote on the log. "Reserve, under these assumptions, is more than we can set aside. The shortfall comes out of tier 3: we are funding the water heater and the roof, and we will meet the furnace and air conditioner with a loan if they fail before we have caught up. We are not reducing the reserve figure to match the money." Underneath it, the comparison: a dollar a square foot would have given them $1,450, which is in the same neighborhood as their arithmetic by coincidence rather than by method, because it knows nothing about the 2009 equipment.
Their conclusion carries its uncertainty: potentially the furnace is the next spend, and what would settle it is the technician's inspection rather than any further arithmetic on the sheet.
- Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, Improving America's Housing 2025 (a PDF): every national spending figure in this chapter, with the years attached.
- Insurance Information Institute, homeowners and renters insurance facts: the claim frequency and average claim size table, credited on the page to ISO.
- IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home: the distinction between improvements, which add to basis, and repairs that merely maintain the home, which do not.
- ENERGY STAR's Seal and Insulate: the bounded figure of up to a 10 percent saving on annual energy bills, with the action it is attached to.
8. Practice Practice
Minimum: one reserve figure and the gap sentence, which is the Start here result. Time: about an hour at the sheet, plus an afternoon of phone calls for quotes. Materials: your systems sheet with ages and service lives in it, the reserve calculator, and a phone.
- Get two real quotes for your two largest components. Quotes for replacement are usually free, and a figure you obtained beats any figure you read.
- Run the reserve box for every row and copy the annual figures into the sheet. The Annual set-aside column is summed in the printed house file.
- Write what you can actually set aside, beside the total. Not what you would like to; what you will.
- Write the gap sentence, naming the tier and the component. One sentence. On the sheet, not in your head.
- Start marking invoices M, R or I as they arrive. It costs a second each and it is the record nobody reconstructs later.
Two exercises. Run the two rules of thumb against your own component arithmetic and write down the difference, which tells you how far wrong you would have been following them. And build the year-by-year view: put every replacement year on a timeline and look for the years where two large components land together, because that clustering is the single most useful thing a reserve can warn you about.
9. Your house Your house
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every cost in your sheet say whether it came from a quote or from a published figure?
- Is the reserve total built from components rather than from a percentage of anything?
- Is there a written sentence naming the tier and the specific component the shortfall comes out of?
- Did you leave the reserve figure honest rather than trimming it to match the money?
- Can you say what your figure rests on, in one sentence, to somebody who asks?
Worked example
The Okonkwos pass on all five. Their costs are marked as quotes, their total is a sum of rows, their gap sentence names tier 3 and names the furnace and air conditioner, and they wrote down explicitly that they were not reducing the reserve. Asked what it rests on, Ray can say: four local quotes, InterNACHI's service lives, three install dates off labels and one assumed roof age.
What is weak is the roof row, and they know it, because the age is assumed. The catch-up figure for that row is therefore the one to treat with the most suspicion, and it changes the moment the permit search comes back.
Common mistakes
- Trimming the reserve to fit the budget. It produces a number that is about your bank account rather than about your house, and then neither number is useful.
- Using a rule of thumb as a budget. Neither rule knows what is in the house, which is what upkeep costs are made of.
- Treating the published averages as a target. They are measurements of what people spent in a year, averaged over tens of millions of households.
- Leaving the gap unnamed. An unnamed shortfall is met by whatever happens first, which is usually the most expensive option.
- Mixing improvements into the reserve. A new kitchen is not a maintenance cost and putting it in the same column hides both numbers.
- Assuming insurance covers the worn-out thing. Sudden and accidental is the usual line, and your policy is the only authority on where it sits.
What is still unresolved
This chapter makes no claim that maintenance saves money overall, and no claim about resale value anywhere. What it claims is narrower: that some published figures attach a stated saving to a stated action, and that a reserve moves a cost from unpredictable to predictable. What it cannot tell you is what your components actually cost to replace in your market, which is why it asks for quotes; or what your policy covers, which is your insurer's; or whether a particular job is a repair or an improvement for tax, which is a tax professional's. The decision about who does the work, which changes most of these numbers, is Hiring help.