Hiring help
Spending money well

Deciding what to hire, finding someone, and paying them

Licensing, deposits, contracts and liens are state law, so this chapter never tells you your state's rule. It tells you what the federal sources say and where to ask.

Start here Essentials

At minimum, take one job all the way from trade to signed contract. Comparing mismatched scopes, liens, permits, emergency work and disaster-zone contractors are Go deeper.

  1. For the first job on your ranked job list, write down what trade it needs (what must be hired).
  2. Confirm one candidate's license with the state or county and ask for proof of insurance (finding someone).
  3. Get written estimates from at least two, each with scope, materials, dates and price (estimates).
  4. Before signing, check the contract against the list in this chapter (the contract).

Minimum time: about two hours of your own, spread across however long the estimates take. Done when: one job has a verified license, two written estimates, and a contract with no blank spaces.

1. What must be hired Understand

The priority rule gives three tests in order: does a failure here hurt someone, does a rule require a certification, and can you reach it safely. Here is what those tests produce as a list, which is the list this manual does not teach around.

WorkWhy it is hiredWhat to ask for
Gas or propane lines, connections and appliances; burnersA failure hurts someoneThe trade's license, verified with the state or county, and proof of insurance
Flues, chimneys and the annual heating inspectionA failure hurts someone; CPSC and USFA both say annually, by a professionalThat the inspection covers chimneys and flues for blockages, corrosion, partial and complete disconnections and loose connections
Electrical panels, breakers, wiring, service entrancesA failure hurts someoneA licensed electrician; verify the license with the state or county
Refrigerant circuitsA failure hurts someone; handling is regulatedA heating and cooling contractor
Anything on a roofFalls from heightA roofer or gutter contractor, and proof of insurance in particular
Paid work disturbing paint in a pre-1978 homeEPA's RRP rule requires certification of the firmThe firm's EPA lead-safe certification, before the estimate
Mold over about 10 square feet, or after a lot of water damageEPA's thresholdA remediation contractor, and the water source found first
Radon mitigationA design question, not a productYour state radon program's list of proficient contractors

On the lead row specifically: EPA's rule requires anyone paid to perform work that disturbs painted surfaces in pre-1978 homes, childcare facilities and preschools to be certified, and it covers all firms including sole proprietorships. The rule text is 40 CFR part 745 subpart E. Ask for the certification before the estimate, because a firm that is not certified cannot legally do the work and the conversation ends there.

Limits

Licensing, permits, deposit limits, contract requirements and lien rules are state law, and in places county or city law. They vary enormously. This manual states no state's rule anywhere. What it gives you is what the federal sources say, the agency to ask (your state or county government, and your state or local consumer protection office), and one state's rule only where it is labeled as an example of how much they vary. It gives no legal advice and does not draft a contract.

2. Finding someone

FTC's published advice, in its own order:

  • Consider only contractors who are licensed and insured. Check with your state or county government to confirm a contractor's license, and ask the contractor for proof of insurance.
  • Get recommendations from people you trust.
  • Check the local Home Builders Association and consumer protection officials for complaints, and search the company name with "scam", "review" or "complaint".
  • Read reviews critically.

The first bullet contains a distinction people skip: the license is verified with the government, the insurance is requested from the contractor. A license number printed on a truck or a card is not a verification, and a contractor who says they are licensed and insured has made a claim rather than provided evidence.

FTC's warning signs

These are the tactics FTC names, and they are worth reading as a set rather than individually, because any one of them can have an innocent explanation and three of them together do not:

  • Knocking on your door looking for business because they are in the area.
  • Saying they have materials left over from a previous job.
  • Pressuring you for an immediate decision.
  • Asking you to pay for everything up front, or only accepting cash.
  • Asking you to get any required building permits.
  • Suggesting you borrow money from a lender they know.

Why the permit one is on the list It is the least obvious of the six. A contractor who asks the homeowner to pull the permits is moving the regulatory relationship, and the liability that goes with it, onto somebody who is not doing the work. FTC lists it as a warning sign, and Go deeper covers who normally pulls a permit.

3. Estimates, compared on scope

FTC's advice: get multiple estimates, each with a description of the work, the materials, the completion date and the price; do not automatically take the lowest bidder; and ask for an explanation where estimates differ widely.

That last clause is where the real work is, and this manual has a method for it, because "ask for an explanation" assumes you can see what to ask about.

The method: write the line items side by side

Take two estimates and make a three-column table: the line item, what estimate A includes, what estimate B includes. Then look only at the rows where one column is empty.

Line itemEstimate AEstimate BThe question
Tear off existing layersOne layerNot statedWhat happens if there are two layers under there?
Deck repairPriced per sheet if neededNot mentionedHow is damaged decking handled and priced?
FlashingNew at chimney and wallsReuse existingReusing flashing is a real choice; is it this roof's right one?
DisposalIncludedNot statedWho pays for the dumpster?
PermitContractor pulls itNot statedFTC's warning sign, if the answer is "you do"
Warranty on laborStated in yearsNot statedWhat is covered, by whom, for how long?

A cheaper estimate is often a smaller scope rather than a better price, and the blank cells are where that shows. The question to ask is not "why are you more expensive" but "what does your price include that theirs does not, and what did you assume about what you will find?"

Two estimates is the minimum this manual's Start here asks for; FTC says multiple, and three is the common practice. For a large job three is worth the time. For a small repair two is usually enough to see whether the first one is in the normal range.

4. The contract

FTC says contract requirements vary by state, and that even where a written agreement is not required you should ask for one. Its list of what the contract should include:

  • The contractor's name, address, phone number and license number.
  • An estimated start date and completion date.
  • Any promises made in conversation, including about scope and about the cost of labor and materials.
  • A written statement of your right to cancel within three business days, if you signed in your home or anywhere other than the seller's permanent place of business.
  • All blank spaces filled in.

Each of those is there because of a specific failure. The license number on the contract is what you can verify. The dates are what makes a delay a departure from the agreement rather than a disappointment. The promises made in conversation is the one people most often skip, and it is the one that costs: a contractor who says "of course we will haul the old units away" and a contract that does not say so is a dispute waiting to be had.

All blanks filled in is the simplest rule in this chapter and the one with the least ambiguity. A blank space in a signed document is a space somebody can fill in later.

FTC's related rules about documents and financing, which belong here as much as anywhere:

  • Never sign a document you have not read, that is in a language you do not understand, or that has blank spaces. Depending on where you live you may be entitled to a copy of the contract in the language the sale was negotiated in.
  • Never agree to contractor-arranged financing without shopping around.
  • Never transfer your deed without advice.

5. The three-business-day cancellation right

This right is real, it is federal, and it is narrower than most people think, so it is worth knowing what it actually covers. The rule is 16 CFR part 429.

What the rule defines as a door-to-door sale: a sale, lease or rental of consumer goods or services in which the seller personally solicits the sale, including in response to an invitation by the buyer, and the buyer's agreement is made somewhere other than the seller's place of business. The examples the rule gives include the buyer's residence, temporarily rented facilities such as hotel rooms, convention centers, fairgrounds and restaurants, the buyer's workplace, and dormitory lounges.

The purchase price thresholds: $25 or more at the buyer's residence, and $130 or more elsewhere.

The required notice reads: "You may CANCEL this transaction, without any Penalty or Obligation, within THREE BUSINESS DAYS from the above date."

The part containing the words "including in response to an invitation by the buyer" is the part people get wrong in the other direction: a contractor you called and asked to come to your house is still personally soliciting a sale at your residence, and the agreement signed at your kitchen table is still covered. The rule also lists transactions the term does not include, which this manual summarizes rather than reproduces; read the rule if the question turns on it.

Ask the authority Your state may give a longer period, a wider scope, or additional requirements. Your state or local consumer protection office is who to ask, and this manual states no state's version.

6. Paying

FTC's three rules about money:

  • Do not pay the full amount up front.
  • Some states actually limit the amount of money a contractor can ask for as a down payment, so contact the state or local consumer agency for the law in your area.
  • Never make the final payment until the work is done and you are satisfied.

Those three together describe a payment schedule: a deposit within whatever your state allows, progress payments tied to work actually completed, and a final payment held until the end. The practical version is to write the schedule into the contract with each payment tied to a stated milestone rather than to a date, because a date arrives whether the work does or not.

The home improvement loan scam

FTC describes a specific pattern, and it is worth knowing in its shape rather than its details. A contractor offers to arrange financing. Then they ask you to sign papers after work has started, sometimes blank. Later you find you have taken out a high-interest home equity loan while the work is unfinished, and the contractor, who may already have been paid by the lender, has stopped returning calls.

Caution

Two things make that pattern work: signing after the work has started, when stopping feels impossible, and signing documents that are blank or unread. Both are in FTC's rules above. If financing is part of a job, arrange it separately, before anything begins, with a lender you found rather than one you were steered to.

7. Service contracts and home warranties

FTC's position, in its own terms: home warranties are really service contracts. They typically cover replacements and repairs for things like appliances or air conditioning systems, they last a set period, and unlike builder warranties for new homes, or warranties included with some products, they cost extra.

FTC also says a home warranty may duplicate coverage you already have, cover only part of a product, or make repairs hard to get.

Its four questions:

  1. Is it likely to save money once deductibles and per-service fees are counted?
  2. What are the limitations? Reimbursement caps, accidental damage, excluded appliances or systems, cancellation restrictions or fees.
  3. Is the claims process difficult or slow?
  4. Does the company have a good reputation? FTC's line: a home warranty is only as good as the company responsible for coverage. Search the company name with "review" or "complaint".

What this manual does not say FTC does not say home warranties are a scam, and neither does this manual. It gives the four questions and leaves the answer to your own contract and your own circumstances. The first question is the one to answer with arithmetic: the annual cost plus the deductible and per-service fees, against what you would otherwise be setting aside in What upkeep costs.

8. When it goes wrong

FTC gives an order, and following it in order matters, because each step builds the record the next one needs.

  1. Try the contractor first. Most problems are resolved here, and skipping it weakens everything after.
  2. Follow phone calls with a letter sent by certified mail with return receipt. This is the step that converts a conversation into a record.
  3. Keep notes and copies of everything: dates, who you spoke to, what was said, what was sent.
  4. Then go outward: the state attorney general or local consumer protection office, the local home builders association, local media Call For Action lines, or dispute resolution programs.

The reported sheet is built for this: date, to whom, what, what they promised, done on. Filled in as you go, it is the record step 3 asks for, already written.

For the conversation itself, which is often the hard part, Learn Conflict Management on this shelf covers how to open a disagreement, make a clear request, and move to a written agreement. This chapter covers the paperwork; that one covers what you actually say.

Go deeper

Comparing two estimates whose scopes genuinely differ

Worked on a fictional roof. Estimate A is higher and specifies tearing off one existing layer, new flashing at the chimney and walls, deck repair priced per sheet if needed, disposal included, the contractor pulling the permit, and a stated labor warranty. Estimate B is lower and specifies reroofing, materials, and a price. The blank cells in B are not evidence of dishonesty; they are evidence that B has not been asked the questions yet. The right move is to send B the same six line items and ask for a revised estimate covering them, which either raises B's price to A's neighborhood or reveals a real difference in method. What you must not do is compare the two numbers as they stand, because they are prices for different jobs.

A handyperson against a licensed trade

Many small repairs do not need a licensed trade, and a competent handyperson is often the right answer for a day's worth of small jobs. The boundary is the list in section 1: gas, flues, panels, refrigerant, roofs, pressurized connections and pre-1978 paint. Where a job sits near that boundary, the questions are whether the work requires a license in your state (the state or county answers that, not the handyperson) and whether they carry insurance. Both matter more on a boundary job than on a hinge adjustment.

What proof of insurance should name

A certificate of insurance names the insurer, the policy numbers, the coverage types and limits, the policy dates and the certificate holder. Two things are worth looking at: that the policy dates cover the period of your work, and that the certificate was issued to you rather than being a photocopy of one issued to somebody else. A certificate requested from the insurer or the agent rather than handed over by the contractor is the stronger version, and asking for that is normal practice rather than an insult.

Permits, and who pulls them

A permit is the local building department's record that work was authorized and will be inspected. The usual practice is that the contractor doing the work pulls it, which is why FTC lists "asking you to get any required building permits" as a warning sign: it moves the regulatory relationship onto the homeowner. Which work needs a permit is set by your city or county, and the building department will tell you if you call and describe the job. Permitted work also leaves the record that Walk your house suggests you search for.

Mechanics liens and lien waivers

A mechanics lien is a claim against a property by somebody who provided labor or materials and has not been paid, and the rules about who can file one, when, and what notice they must give are state law and vary a great deal. A lien waiver is a document in which that right is released, usually in exchange for payment. Because the rules are so variable, this manual states none of them; your state's consumer protection office or a lawyer is who to ask, and it is a question worth asking before a large job rather than during a dispute.

Emergency work, where there is no time for estimates

Sometimes there is no time for three estimates: a tree is on the roof, a pipe has burst, the heat has failed in a cold snap. What you protect in that situation is not price, it is the record. Write down who you called and when, what they said they would do, and what they charged. Photograph the condition before anyone works on it. Get something in writing even if it is a text message. And deal with the emergency in two stages where you can: the stabilizing work now, the permanent repair on a normal process next week.

Disaster-zone contractors

FTC's warning signs apply with particular force after a storm or a flood, when out-of-area contractors arrive in numbers, pressure is high, and the door-knocking tactic is at its most plausible. The same advice holds and is harder to follow: verify the license with the state or county, ask for proof of insurance, do not pay everything up front, and do not sign anything with a blank in it. The three-business-day cancellation right applies to a sale solicited at your residence, which describes most of these.

When the project has grown past upkeep

This chapter is about hiring for maintenance and small repairs. When a job becomes a renovation project with multiple trades, a design, a permit set and a schedule, it is a different activity with different documents and a different relationship. Learn General Contracting on this shelf covers that: bids, permits, scheduling, sequencing and managing a project. The line is not sharp, and a useful test is whether you are hiring one trade to do a defined task or coordinating several over weeks.

9. See it See it

Fictional example

Odette Baptiste, the 1920s farmhouse outside Burlington, Vermont. Retired, hires most work. Her first job is the one from Air, moisture and insulation: air sealing and insulating the crawl space, in a house built long before 1978.

Known. The trade is an insulation contractor. The house is pre-1978, so paid work disturbing painted surfaces brings EPA's rule into it; she established on the phone, before asking for an estimate, that the two firms she called are EPA lead-safe certified. She confirmed both licenses with the state rather than taking the number off the paperwork, and asked each for proof of insurance addressed to her.

Assumed, and it is Odette's: that the crawl space work will not disturb painted surfaces, since it is below the living space. She has written that down as an assumption rather than a fact, because the access hatch and its trim are painted, and the contractor's own assessment is what settles it. She asked both firms the question directly and recorded both answers.

Still open, with who settles each: whether her crawl space should be sealed or vented, which is an assembly question for the contractor and depends on her foundation and climate; and whether her oil boiler's combustion will be affected by tightening the house, which is a question for her heating technician and which she has scheduled for the same month, following the caution in Air, moisture and insulation.

Her two estimates, side by side. The cheaper one does not mention the hatch, says nothing about a vapor control layer, and gives a price and a week. The more expensive one specifies air sealing the rim joist, a ground cover, insulation to a stated R-value, what happens to the hatch, and a labor warranty in years. She sent the cheaper firm the five line items from the other estimate and asked for a revised figure. The revised figure came back within 8 percent of the higher one, which told her what she needed to know: the gap was scope, not price.

What she signed. A contract with the firm's name, address, phone and license number, estimated start and completion dates, the five line items including the hatch, the labor warranty they had described on the phone, the three-business-day cancellation statement (she signed at her kitchen table), a payment schedule tied to milestones with the final payment on completion, and no blank spaces. The conversation about the hatch, which had happened verbally, is in the contract because she asked for it to be.

Her conclusion, with its uncertainty intact. Under the assumption that the crawl space work stays clear of painted surfaces, the lead question does not bind her own hands, and both firms are certified anyway, which is the belt-and-braces position she wanted. What would settle the assumption is the contractor's walk-through on day one, and she has asked to be called if it turns out otherwise.

10. Practice Practice

Minimum: one job, one verified license, two written estimates and a contract check, which is the Start here result. Time: about two hours of your own across a week or two. Materials: your ranked job list, a phone, and the log to record calls.

  1. Take the first job on your list and name the trade, using the who-to-call table. If the job needs a certification, establish that on the first phone call.
  2. Verify one license with the state or county, which is a web search or a phone call, and record where you verified it and when.
  3. Ask both candidates for written estimates with scope, materials, dates and price, and ask each the same questions so the answers are comparable.
  4. Build the line-item table and send the shorter estimate the missing rows, asking for a revised figure rather than an explanation.
  5. Check the contract against FTC's list before signing, and have any verbal promise written in. Fill every blank or strike it through.
Go deeper

Two exercises. Call your building department and ask which of the jobs on your list need a permit and who normally pulls them, which takes ten minutes and answers a question FTC treats as a warning sign. And write your own standard question list, the six or eight things you will ask every contractor from now on, and keep it with the house file, because asking everybody the same questions is what makes answers comparable.

11. Your house Your house

12. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Did you verify the license with the government rather than reading it off the contractor's paperwork?
  • Do your estimates cover the same scope, or do you know exactly where they differ and why?
  • Does the contract contain every item on FTC's list, with no blank spaces?
  • Is every promise made in conversation written into the contract?
  • Is the final payment tied to completion and your satisfaction rather than to a date?

Worked example

Odette passes on all five. The one that did the most work was the second: she did not compare the two prices as they stood, she made them comparable first, and the revised figure coming back within 8 percent is what turned a confusing gap into a settled question. The one that took the least effort was the fourth: the hatch promise went into the contract because she asked for it, which took one sentence in an email.

What her file now holds is a verified license with the date and the source, two estimates, a line-item comparison, a signed contract, and a log row for every call. If the job goes wrong, step 3 of FTC's complaint order is already done.

Common mistakes

  • Taking the license number off the contractor's own paperwork. That is a claim. The state or county is the verification.
  • Comparing prices for different scopes. The cheaper estimate is usually a smaller job, and the blank cells are where it shows.
  • Leaving a verbal promise verbal. FTC lists promises made in conversation as something the contract should include, and it is the item most often skipped.
  • Signing with blanks in it. The simplest rule here, and a blank is a space somebody else can fill.
  • Paying in full up front, or in cash only. Both are on FTC's warning list.
  • Agreeing to contractor-arranged financing on the spot. Arrange financing separately and before the work starts.
  • Pulling the permits yourself because the contractor asked. FTC names that request as a warning sign.
  • Asking for an explanation instead of a revised estimate. An explanation is a conversation; a revised estimate is a comparable number.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot tell you your state's rules about licensing, deposits, contracts or liens, and does not try: the state or county government and your state or local consumer protection office are the authorities, and nothing here is legal advice. It cannot tell you whether a particular contractor is good, only how to check what can be checked. It does not cover running a renovation project with several trades, which is Learn General Contracting on this shelf. And it does not cover the conversation when something has gone wrong, which is Learn Conflict Management.

13. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does FTC treat "asking you to get the required building permits" as a warning sign?
Because the contractor doing the work normally pulls the permit, and moving that onto the homeowner moves the regulatory relationship, and the liability with it, onto somebody who is not doing the work. It can also be a signal that the contractor cannot pull one.
You called a contractor and asked them to come to your house. Does the three-business-day cancellation right apply?
The rule's definition of a door-to-door sale includes a seller personally soliciting the sale, including in response to an invitation by the buyer, with the agreement made somewhere other than the seller's place of business. Your kitchen table is such a place, and the threshold at a residence is $25. Your state may give more; your state or local consumer protection office is who to ask.
One roofing estimate is $4,000 less than the other. What is the first thing to do?
Build the line-item table and find the empty cells. Tear-off layers, deck repair, flashing, disposal, permit and labor warranty are the usual places a scope differs. Then send the shorter estimate the missing rows and ask for a revised figure rather than an explanation, because a revised figure is comparable and an explanation is not.
(Go deeper) A contractor offers to arrange financing for a job and asks you to sign the paperwork once the work has started. What is happening?
That is the shape FTC describes in the home improvement loan scam: signing after the work is underway, when stopping feels impossible, sometimes with blanks in the documents, ending in a high-interest home equity loan with unfinished work. Arrange financing separately, before anything begins, with a lender you found yourself.
Somebody knocks on your door after a storm, says they are working on a neighbor's roof and have materials left over, and offers you a price good today if you pay half in cash now. What do you do?
Four of FTC's six warning signs are in that single paragraph: door-knocking because they are in the area, leftover materials, pressure for an immediate decision, and cash up front. Any one has an innocent explanation; four together do not. If the storm did damage your roof, that is a reason to start the normal process today rather than a reason to shorten it.
Improving one warning sign leaves the other three in place, and a contract signed under time pressure with somebody you have not checked is not much protection. You would also be relying on the three-business-day right, which exists and is not a substitute for not signing.
Verifying the license is the right instinct and it is one check against a pattern with four warning signs in it. Do it by all means, and do it while getting other estimates rather than while somebody waits on your doorstep for a decision.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.

Have you just done what this manual teaches? If it is still fresh, we would like to hear about it. We are looking for volunteer guides to add a few short passages from their own experience to this manual. Write to guides@learnthings.online for the details.