Putting home maintenance in order: what comes first and why
Five tiers, each resting on a published figure, and three tests for who does the work. The output is a ranked list with a tier, a who and a date on every row.
Start here Essentials
At minimum, get a tier and a who onto every row you already have, and three dates onto the top of the list. The condo and rental variations, the insurance question and the deferred-maintenance material are Go deeper.
- Copy your unsorted list from the walk-through onto the ranked job list, one row per thing noticed.
- Give each row a tier using the five definitions, and write what it protects in the next column (the five tiers).
- Give each row a who, using the three tests in order (who does it).
- Pick the three tier 1 and tier 2 rows you will finish first and give each a date (writing it down).
Minimum time: about an hour. Done when: the ranked job list has a tier and a who on every row, and a date on at least three.
1. Why a list is the wrong shape Understand
Every home maintenance course we looked at produces a list of jobs. The lists are accurate and they are usually well organized by area or by season. They share one problem, which is that the list is nearly always longer than the year.
A householder with twenty-two rows and two free weekends does not need a longer list or a better one. They need to know which four rows to do, and the honest reason the other eighteen are waiting. Without that, one of three things happens: the most visible job gets done (which is usually the least important one), the easiest job gets done, or nothing gets done and the list becomes a source of guilt rather than a tool.
So this chapter does the thing the lists do not. It puts upkeep into five tiers and says why the order is that way, with a published figure behind each tier, and then it answers the second question every row raises, which is who does it.
Convention The five tiers are this manual's framework. The evidence inside each tier is published and attributed; the decision to group jobs this way and rank them in this order is ours, and you should be able to see the reasoning well enough to disagree with it in your own house.
The tiers rank risk, not urgency in a particular house. A tier 4 job on a component that is actively failing can be the most urgent thing in the building. This rule is for planning a year, not for the morning after a pipe bursts. If something is happening right now, stop reading, shut the water off at the main you labeled in Walk your house, and deal with it.
2. The five tiers
Tier 1: water going where it should not
Roof, gutters, downspouts, grading, basement and crawl space, plumbing leaks, ice dams, condensation.
Why it is first. It is the most frequent loss a householder actually controls, and the fastest to compound. The Insurance Information Institute, citing ISO data, reports that over 2018 to 2022 water damage and freezing ran 1.50 claims per 100 insured house years at an average claim of $15,400, and states that about one in 60 insured homes has a property damage claim caused by water damage or freezing. Wind and hail is the only category that runs more often, and a householder cannot do much about wind.
The compounding is the second half of it. EPA's guidance is to dry water-damaged areas and items within 24 to 48 hours, and that if wet or damp materials are dried within that window, in most cases mold will not grow. A leak found on day one is a plumbing repair. The same leak found in month three is a plumbing repair plus drywall, insulation, flooring and possibly a remediation contractor.
And the fixes are unusually cheap for what they prevent. University of Minnesota Extension and Kansas State Research and Extension both put most basement water back onto the gutters, downspouts and the grade, which is to say onto work that costs tens of dollars rather than thousands. Keeping water out is the chapter.
Tier 2: the failures that are not recoverable
Smoke alarms, carbon monoxide alarms, the annual heating and flue inspection, chimneys, dryer vents, clearances around heat sources.
Why it is second. These are rarer than water and they are irreversible. CPSC reports that more than 200 people in the United States die every year from accidental non-fire related carbon monoxide poisoning associated with consumer products, and that more than 100 of those deaths are linked to portable generators. The US Fire Administration reports that home portable heater fires were 3 percent of all home heating fires annually for 2017 to 2019 but accounted for 41 percent of fatal heating fires in homes.
That second pair of numbers is the whole argument for the tier. A category that is 3 percent of the events and 41 percent of the deaths is not ranked by how often it happens. Tier 2 work is also unusually cheap and fast: pressing four test buttons and writing the date takes ten minutes, and the annual heating service is a phone call. Alarms, vents and tests is the chapter.
Tier 3: equipment that fails expensively, on a schedule
Water heater, furnace or boiler, air conditioner or heat pump, roof covering, major appliances.
Why it is third. These have published service lives and knowable replacement costs, which means they can be funded rather than reacted to. That is the entire difference between a planned expense and a crisis, and it is available for free to anybody who writes down an install date. Harvard's Joint Center reports that in 2023 average per owner maintenance spending on homes built before 1980 ran 76 percent higher than on homes built since 2010, which is a reason to expect this tier to be busier on an older house. What wears out and when and What upkeep costs are the chapters.
Tier 4: money that leaks every day
Filters, duct sealing, air sealing and insulation, dripping fixtures, water heater temperature.
Why it is fourth. This is real money with published figures attached, and delaying it costs only the running total rather than a component or a person. ENERGY STAR says sealing and insulating ducts can improve the efficiency of a heating and cooling system by as much as 20 percent, and sometimes much more. It says sealing air leaks and adding insulation can provide up to a 10 percent saving on annual energy bills. EPA WaterSense says fixing easily corrected household leaks can save a homeowner about 10 percent on the water bill.
Each of those is a bounded estimate attached to a specific action, which is why this manual quotes them with the action and the bound intact. None of them is a claim that maintenance saves money in general.
Tier 5: what only looks bad
Paint, cosmetic caulk lines, worn finishes, tired fixtures.
Why it is last, and why it is here at all. This is the only tier you can honestly set aside for a year. It is on the list so that setting it aside is a decision you made rather than a thing you feel bad about every time you walk past it. Write the row, give it tier 5, give it the who value "not this year", and stop carrying it.
The exception, and it matters: a tier 5 item that protects a material is not cosmetic. Exterior paint on wood is a weather barrier. Caulk at a tub surround is keeping water out of a wall. Those move up, and section 4 says how.
3. Sorting your own list
Take the unsorted list from Walk your house and work down it once. For each row, one question: what does this protect? The answer puts it in a tier, and it goes in the next column so the tier is auditable later.
| Row as written on the walk | What it protects | Tier |
|---|---|---|
| Gutter above porch is loose at one end | Keeps roof water off the foundation | 1 |
| Paint peeling on the same gutter's fascia | The wood behind it, slowly | 5, moving to 4 if the wood is exposed |
| No alarm in the back bedroom | The people asleep in it | 2 |
| Furnace has no service sticker since 2009 | The heat exchanger and the flue; a CO question | 2 for the inspection, 3 for the equipment |
| Dishwasher is noisy | Nothing, yet | 3, watch |
| Bathroom fan is loud and slow | Moisture leaving the house | 4, and 1 if the duct ends in the attic |
| Stain on joist under the upstairs bathroom | Unknown until you know if it is active | 1 until proven otherwise |
Two things that table demonstrates. A single object can produce rows in two tiers, and splitting them is right: the gutter and the gutter's paint are different jobs with different deadlines. And an unknown goes in tier 1 until it is resolved, because the cheapest time to find out whether a stain is active is now, and the test is free.
4. The three ties the rule does not break
A ranking that produces no ties is usually hiding something. These three come up constantly and the rule does not settle them on its own.
- A tier 3 item whose failure causes a tier 1 problem is treated as tier 1. A water heater in a finished basement. A washing machine on a second floor. A sump pump in a basement with anything in it. The component's remaining life is a tier 3 fact; where it would land the water is a tier 1 fact, and the second one wins.
- A tier 4 item that is nearly free is done while you are there. You are in the basement looking at the water heater anyway; turning its thermostat down to 120 degrees Fahrenheit takes a minute. Ranking exists to allocate scarce attention, and a job that costs no additional trip does not consume any.
- A tier 5 item that protects a material is not cosmetic. Paint on bare wood, failed caulk at a wet joint, a sealant line at a window head. These are tier 4 or tier 1 depending on what is behind them, and the question to ask is whether water or weather reaches a material when the finish fails.
Consequence, not category All three exceptions are the same idea: rank by what the failure does in your house, not by what kind of object it is. The tiers are a starting classification, and the consequence overrules the classification when the two disagree.
5. Who does it
Every row needs a second decision, and in most courses it arrives in the last module, long after the reader has already started. It belongs here, with the ranking, because for a lot of rows the answer changes what the row costs and therefore where it sits.
Three tests, in order. The first two are not preferences.
Test 1: does a failure here hurt someone?
Gas and propane lines and appliances, burners, flues and chimneys. Electrical panels, breakers, wiring and service entrances. Refrigerant circuits. Anything carried out on a roof. Pressurized plumbing connections and a water heater's fuel or electrical connections. Structural members.
These are hired, in this manual, without exception for skill or confidence. The who-to-call table names the trade for each and what to ask for.
Test 2: does a rule require a certification?
The clearest example is lead paint. EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting rule requires anyone paid to perform work that disturbs painted surfaces in pre-1978 homes, childcare facilities and preschools to be certified, and that covers all firms including sole proprietorships. EPA states that in general the rule does not apply to homeowners doing the work in their own pre-1978 home, with exceptions: if you rent out all or part of the home, operate a childcare center in it, or buy, renovate and sell homes for profit, you are inside it.
EPA also reports that approximately three-quarters of US homes built before 1978 still contain some lead-based paint, and that children can live safely in those homes as long as paint and surfaces are in good condition and kept clean. Alarms, vents and tests works through settling the question before anything is sanded, scraped or demolished.
Ask the authority Other certifications and licenses are set by state, county or city, and they vary enormously. This manual states no state's rule. It names the agency to ask, which is the state or county government, and FTC's own advice is to confirm a license with them rather than with the contractor.
Test 3: can you reach it safely?
This is why the setup form asks about ladders. A job above ground level that you are not steady on is not a job you have, whatever your skill with the work itself. Falls from height are a different category of outcome from a botched repair, and there is no version of this chapter where a reader is encouraged to try it anyway.
If you answered that you would rather not use a ladder, or cannot, every gutter, roof-adjacent and high-window row in your list has a trade in the who column. Write it in. A blank cell on those rows is how they stay undone for three years.
The fourth test, which is honest rather than technical
Will you actually do it?
A job assigned to yourself and not done for two years is worse than the same job assigned to a trade on a Tuesday, because the first one is also occupying space on a list and generating a small amount of guilt every time you read it. If a row has been yours for two years and has not moved, the correct action is to change the who column rather than to try harder.
That is not an argument for hiring everything. It is an argument for the who column reflecting what is going to happen rather than what you would like to be true about yourself.
6. Writing the result down
The output of this chapter is the ranked job list with six columns filled: the job, the tier, what it protects, who does it, an estimated cost where you have one, and a date on the rows you are actually committing to.
Three things about the dates, because this is where plans usually fail.
- Date three rows, not thirty. A list where everything has a date is a list where nothing does.
- Put the dates where the time actually is. A row dated for a weekend you will be away is a row that slips and takes the plan's credibility with it.
- Leave the undated rows undated on purpose. An undated tier 3 row with a who and a cost is a funded, named decision. It is not an oversight.
Then the line. Draw it where your year runs out, explicitly, and write what is under it. "Not this year: exterior paint on the south elevation, replacing the upstairs vanity, the deck boards" is a sentence that stops you paying for those rows in attention all year. What upkeep costs does the same thing with money, where the question is which tier a funding shortfall comes out of.
The tiers in a condo, a co-op or a rental
If somebody else owns the building's envelope and its mechanical systems, they own most of tier 1 and much of tier 3. That does not delete those rows; it changes their who column and their output. The work that is yours becomes reporting, in writing, with dates, which is what the reported sheet is for. Tier 2 inside your own door is the clearest thing you own: the alarms are yours to test and to report on whoever installed them.
What is yours and what is theirs comes from the association's documents or the lease and your state's landlord-tenant law, and from nowhere else. This manual does not state what any of those say.
When a tier 1 and a tier 2 item compete for the same weekend
Do the tier 2 one first if it is short, which it usually is. Pressing test buttons and writing dates is a ten-minute job; regrading a flower bed is an afternoon. The ranking is about which to drop when you cannot do both, and in practice tier 2 rarely competes for time with anything, because it is so cheap. Where it does compete is for the annual service appointment, which should be booked out of season rather than in the first cold week.
Arguing a case in writing to a landlord or an association
The tiers are a useful structure for a written request because they put the reason in front of the ask. A request that opens with what the failure would cost, cites the published figure, states what you observed and when, and asks for a specific action is a different document from a complaint. Learn Conflict Management, another manual on this shelf, covers the conversation itself, including what to do when the first written request produces nothing.
Deferred maintenance, and why naming it is better
Deferred maintenance is work that is needed and has not been done. The term is usually used about institutions, and it is just as applicable to a house. The difference between deferred and forgotten is a written record of the deferral: the row, the tier, the reason, and the date you will look at it again. A deferral you wrote down is a position. A deferral you did not is an accumulating surprise, and it is the thing that turns a sale, a refinance or an inspection into bad news.
Insurance and maintenance exclusions
Homeowners policies generally cover sudden and accidental damage rather than wear, deterioration or a maintenance failure, and the line between them is drawn by the policy's own wording and by the insurer. This manual states nothing about what your policy covers, because only your policy and your insurer can. What is worth knowing from the published side is the Insurance Information Institute's figures on how often each category of claim happens, which is the evidence behind tier 1 rather than advice about coverage. If a tier 1 row in your house looks like it could become a claim, the conversation to have is with your insurer, before rather than after.
7. See it See it
Ray and Diane Okonkwo brought twenty-two unsorted rows to this chapter. Both work full time and have about two hours a month. Ray will not go on a ladder. Here is the top of their sheet after an hour.
| Job | Tier | What it protects | Who | By when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stain on joist under upstairs bathroom: mark it and recheck | 1 | Unknown until resolved; the floor structure if active | Me | This weekend |
| Two downspouts discharge at the wall; measure and extend | 1 | The basement, which is finished | Me | Next weekend |
| No alarm in the back bedroom; buy and fit two | 2 | The people asleep | Me | This weekend |
| Book the annual furnace and flue service | 2 | A CO question, and the heat exchanger | A licensed trade | September |
| Water heater, 2016, over a finished floor: price a pan | 1 (moved from 3) | The basement floor and what is on it | A licensed trade | Undated; funded |
| Clear and reseat the loose gutter above the porch | 1 | The same foundation corner | A licensed trade | Undated; Ray will not use a ladder |
| Peeling paint on the porch fascia | 4 (moved from 5) | Bare wood is exposed | A licensed trade | Not this year |
| Dishwasher is noisy | 3 | Nothing yet; watch | Me | Not this year |
Known: the water heater's 2016 date, the furnace's 2009 sticker, and the fact that the basement is finished.
Assumed, and it is Ray's assumption: that the joist stain is historic rather than active. He has marked its edge with a pencil and dated it, so the assumption has a test attached and a week to run.
Still open, with who settles each: the gutter (a gutter contractor, because of the ladder answer); the pan under the water heater (a plumber's price); and whether the fascia's bare wood has gone soft, which Ray can settle with a thumbnail from the ground on a stepladder's bottom step, or leave for the gutter contractor to look at while they are up there.
Their line is drawn after row six. Under it: the fascia paint, the dishwasher, and twelve other rows. Written down, with the word "not this year" in the who column, which is the point.
- Insurance Information Institute, homeowners and renters insurance facts: the claim frequencies and average claim sizes by cause that tier 1 rests on, credited on the page to ISO.
- EPA's Brief Guide to Mold, Moisture, and Your Home: the 24 to 48 hour drying window, and the 10 square foot threshold for who does a cleanup.
- US Fire Administration on home heating fire safety: the portable heater figures behind tier 2, the 3 foot clearance, and the annual professional inspection of heating equipment and chimneys.
- EPA's Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting Program: who the rule binds, the homeowner exception and the three situations that cancel it.
8. Practice Practice
Minimum: a tier and a who on every row, and three dates, which is the Start here result. Time: about an hour for twenty rows. Materials: your unsorted list, the ranked job list open, and the who-to-call table in another tab.
- Work down the list once asking only "what does this protect". Write the answer before you write the tier; the answer is what makes the tier defensible.
- Do a second pass for the three ties. Look for tier 3 items over something expensive, tier 4 items that are free while you are there, and tier 5 items with a material behind them.
- Apply the three who tests in order to every row, and do not let the third test or your own preference overrule the first two.
- Date three rows and draw the line. Write what is under the line in a sentence, somewhere you will read it.
- Put the undated tier 3 rows into the reserve calculator so that "not this year" means funded rather than ignored.
Two exercises. Re-sort somebody else's list: ask a friend what is on their house list and tier it with them, which exposes how much of your own sorting was habit. And write the one-page case for the row you most want somebody else to pay for, whether that is a landlord, an association or a household member, with the tier, the published figure, what you observed and the specific ask.
9. Your house Your house
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every row say what it protects, in words, rather than just carrying a tier number?
- Is there at least one row whose tier you changed because of where it sits rather than what it is?
- Does every row have a who, with no blanks? A blank who is a row nobody owns.
- Are there exactly a few dated rows rather than many, and are the dates on weekends you will actually be there?
- Have you written the "not this year" sentence somewhere other than in your head?
Worked example
The Okonkwos pass on all five. Their What it protects column is in plain words. The water heater moved from tier 3 to tier 1 because of the finished basement. Every row has a who, including the three that say "not this year". They dated four rows, not twenty. And their line is written on the sheet with the rows under it named.
What the sheet does not do, and should not, is resolve the joist stain. That row is dated for this weekend with a test attached, which is the correct treatment of an unknown: not a guess at a tier, but a short deadline on finding out.
Common mistakes
- Ranking by what is visible. The thing that bothers you from the street is usually tier 5. The thing doing damage is usually invisible from anywhere.
- Leaving the who column blank on the hard rows. Those are exactly the rows that need a name in them, because they are the ones that will not happen by accident.
- Letting preference beat the first two tests. Wanting to do your own gas work does not make it yours. Nor does competence.
- Dating everything. It feels like commitment and it functions like noise.
- Treating an unknown as a low tier. An unresolved stain or smell sits in tier 1 until a cheap test moves it, because the cost of being wrong is asymmetric.
- Using the tiers during an actual emergency. They are a planning tool. Water coming through a ceiling is not a planning situation.
What is still unresolved
The ranking does not tell you what anything costs, which is What upkeep costs, nor when in the year to do it, which is Your own calendar. It does not find the person named in the who column, which is Hiring help. And it does not tell you whether a condition in your house is actually a problem; that is the job of the chapters on each system and, for anything you cannot see, of the trades in the who-to-call table.