Keeping water out: roof, gutters, grading and the basement
Water is the most frequent loss a householder actually controls, and most of the fixes are at the cheap end of the path it takes. Follow that path from the roof to the foundation.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. The path water takes
- 2. Gutters and downspouts
- 3. Grading
- 4. The roof, from the ground
- 5. A wet basement or crawl space
- 6. Plumbing leaks and the meter test
- 7. When something is already wet
- 8. See it
- 9. Practice
- 10. Your house
- 11. Check your work
- 12. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
At minimum, watch where the roof water lands, count your downspouts, extend them, and read your meter. The Minnesota and Kansas State comparison, interior drainage, gutter guards and the water bill units are Go deeper.
- In rain, or with a hose on the roof, watch where the water lands and write it down corner by corner (gutters and downspouts).
- Count your downspouts against your eave length with the drainage calculator.
- Add or extend downspouts so each discharges at least 4 feet from the wall, which is Minnesota Extension's figure (gutters and downspouts).
- Read your water meter, wait two hours with nothing running, and read it again (plumbing leaks).
Minimum time: about three hours, spread over a rainy day and a quiet one. Done when: every downspout you have discharges at least 4 feet out, or you have written down that there are none, and the meter sheet has two readings and a gallons-per-day figure.
1. The path water takes Understand
Water from the sky lands on a roof, runs to an edge, goes into a gutter, down a downspout, onto the ground, and then either away from the house or toward it. That is the whole path, and almost every expensive water problem in a house is a failure somewhere along it.
The useful thing about the path is that the cost of fixing it rises sharply from one end to the other.
| Where on the path | Typical fix | Rough order of cost |
|---|---|---|
| Downspout extension | A length of extension, or a buried line | Tens of dollars |
| Gutter cleared or reseated | A visit | Low hundreds |
| Grade corrected | Soil, a shovel, an afternoon or a small contractor | Low hundreds |
| Interior drainage system or sump | A contractor, a day or more | Thousands |
| Footing drains retrofitted | Excavation | Kansas State describes this as likely to be expensive |
| Remediation after the fact | Drying, demolition, replacement | III reports an average water damage and freezing claim of $15,400 over 2018 to 2022 |
Work from the cheap end This is the chapter's method and it is also what two extension services say. University of Minnesota Extension and Kansas State Research and Extension both put most basement water back onto the gutters, downspouts and the surface grade. Kansas State cites a study that found improperly installed footing drainage systems in more than 90 percent of wet basement cases, which sounds like the opposite point until you notice what it implies: the part that is actually failing is the part you cannot inspect, cannot cheaply repair, and can most usefully take load off by handling the water before it ever gets there.
So: start at the top of the path, work down, and do not buy anything until you know where the water is arriving.
2. Gutters and downspouts
Three published figures govern this section, all from University of Minnesota Extension:
- A minimum of one downspout per 50 linear feet of roof eave.
- Extensions should discharge water at least 4 feet beyond the wall.
- A downspout without an extender or splash block is worse than no downspout at all, because it concentrates the whole roof's rainwater in one place beside the basement.
That third one is the sentence worth remembering, and it is counterintuitive enough that people resist it. A roof with no gutters sheds water along its entire drip line, distributed. A gutter system with one downspout dumping at the foundation takes the same volume and delivers it to a single spot a foot from the basement wall. The gutter has concentrated the problem.
The drainage calculator does the counting: enter your total eave length and the number of downspouts you have, and it gives you the number the published figure calls for and how many to add. Measure the eave rather than estimating it; the count comes straight off that number.
Clearing them
UGA's checklist puts gutter cleaning in both the spring and the fall list, and adds that it may need to be done more frequently. Convention Twice a year is a default rather than an interval anybody measured. Your trees set the real frequency: a house under oaks that hold their leaves into winter is on a different schedule from a house under a maple.
The test is direct. After a heavy rain, look at the downspout outlets. If water is coming out of them at a rate that matches the rain, the gutters are flowing. If water is sheeting over the gutter edge, they are not.
Nothing in this manual asks you to work from a ladder you are not steady on, and nothing asks you to go onto a roof. If you answered that you would rather not use a ladder, or cannot, this section is a hired job: a gutter contractor or a handyperson, named in the Who column of your ranked job list. Falls from height are a different category of outcome from a botched repair.
Where the water should go
Four feet is Minnesota's minimum. Further is better where you can get it, and the direction matters as much as the distance: an extension that discharges onto ground sloping back toward the house has moved the problem four feet and solved nothing. Penn State Extension's guidance on controlling stormwater on your own property makes the same point about directing all downspouts away from foundations.
What to discharge onto, in rough order of preference: a sloped hard surface that carries water away, a splash block onto ground that falls away, a buried solid line to daylight. What to avoid: a bed that holds water against the wall, a surface that freezes into an ice sheet across a path, and a neighbor's property, which is a conversation rather than a drainage decision.
3. Grading
The grade is the slope of the ground surface next to the foundation. It is the second cheap control on the path, and the one that quietly reverses itself over time as backfill settles.
The figure this manual states: University of Minnesota Extension says to place earth around the house so that it slopes away from the foundation wall a minimum of 1 inch per foot for at least 6 feet. That is the minimum and it is achievable on most lots.
Kansas State Research and Extension gives a different target: sloping away for 15 feet at about one inch per foot is ideal, and water should not be allowed to accumulate within 15 feet of the foundation. Kansas State also warns that backfill settles and can reverse the slope that was there when the house was built.
Two publications, two figures Both are current extension publications and they are addressing the same problem at different levels of ambition. This manual states Minnesota's 6 feet as the minimum to work to, because it is reachable on a small lot, and shows Kansas State's 15 feet in Go deeper rather than hiding it. If you have 15 feet, use it.
Measuring a slope
You need a straight board, a level and a tape. Lay the board on the ground running away from the wall, put the level on it, lift the far end until the bubble centers, and measure the gap between the board's far end and the ground. That gap, over the board's length, is your fall. A 6 foot board with a 6 inch gap is 1 inch per foot.
The drainage calculator will tell you how much fall the published figure asks for over whatever distance you can actually grade, and will say where that distance sits against both publications' figures.
Three things that commonly defeat a grade, all findable on a walk: a flower bed edged with timber that holds water in; a patio or path that has settled toward the house; and mulch piled against siding, which also puts organic material in contact with the wall. Virginia Cooperative Extension's guidance on subterranean termites covers the related reason to care about wood-to-soil contact and moisture beside a foundation, which is that the conditions that let water in are the conditions that attract termites.
4. The roof, from the ground
What you can assess from the ground with binoculars: missing, lifted, curled or cracked shingles; a sagging or wavy ridge line; granules collecting at the downspout outlets; moss or plants growing on the surface; the condition of flashing where a chimney, a wall or a vent penetrates; and whether anything is leaning on it.
What you cannot assess from the ground: everything else.
The published service life from the service life table, plus whatever install date you established in Walk your house, gives you a planning horizon. What wears out and when is explicit that this is a trigger for an opinion rather than an opinion. A roof inside three years of its published life is a roof to have somebody look at.
Nobody in this manual goes onto a roof. That is not a caution about care; it is a rule, and it applies to a reader who is comfortable on a ladder as much as to one who is not. Roof work is a roofer's. What a householder does with a roof is look at it from the ground, know its age, and get somebody up there when the age or the view says to.
5. A wet basement or crawl space
The whole method here is one instruction: find the source before you buy anything. The products sold for wet basements are mostly for a specific source, and bought without knowing the source, most of them do nothing.
Three sources, told apart
| Source | What it looks like | How to tell |
|---|---|---|
| Condensation | Damp surfaces, wet cold pipes, sometimes a musty smell, worse in humid weather | Tape a square of foil or plastic tightly to the wall. Moisture on the room side after a day or two is condensation |
| Seepage | Wet after rain, often at a specific spot, dries between rains | Same foil test: moisture on the wall side means water coming through the masonry |
| Groundwater | Water arriving at the floor-wall joint or up through the floor, worst in wet seasons | Timing and location: it follows the water table rather than individual rainfalls |
Test it The foil test is cheap, slow and decisive, and it is the single most useful diagnostic in this chapter. Tape several squares in different places, because a basement can have two sources at once.
Why a dehumidifier is not the answer
University of Minnesota Extension is direct about this: dehumidification is not a permanent or complete solution, and in a basement with moisture problems it may cause greater damage, by drawing moisture in faster and causing efflorescence and spalling of the concrete.
That is a specific published caution and it is worth taking literally. A dehumidifier is a reasonable tool for a dry basement with humid air. In a basement where water is coming through the wall, it is a machine that accelerates the process pulling water through the masonry.
The order of work
- Gutters flowing, downspouts counted, extensions at 4 feet or more. This is where most of it ends, according to both Minnesota and Kansas State.
- Grade corrected to the published minimum where you can reach it.
- Surface features fixed: the bed that holds water, the path that has settled, the window well with no drainage.
- Then, and only then, a specialist. A basement still wet after all of that is a question for somebody who does this work, not a question for a product.
You can see where water arrives and where the ground slopes. You cannot see a footing drain, a failed membrane or a cracked drain line under a slab, and the published figure that most wet basements trace to footing drainage is precisely the part you cannot inspect. What the cheap fixes settle is whether the problem was ever about the easy end of the path. What they cannot settle is the rest, and a basement still wet after the gutters, extensions and grade are right is a specialist's question rather than a product's.
Crawl spaces deserve a sentence of their own, because they are easier to ignore and harder to see into. Everything above applies, with the difference that nobody notices a crawl space problem for years. Look at it on a schedule rather than when something smells, and put the schedule on your calendar.
6. Plumbing leaks and the meter test
The other half of tier 1 is water the house is supplying to itself.
The test. Turn everything off: no taps, no dishwasher, no washing machine, no ice maker filling, and tell anybody else in the house. Read the meter, including the small dial or triangle that turns on any flow. Wait two hours. Read it again. Any change is water going somewhere.
The leak calculator takes the two readings, the units (cubic feet, gallons or hundred cubic feet) and the hours, and gives you gallons a day, with EPA's two published comparisons printed beside it.
What EPA publishes. Household leaks waste nearly 1 trillion gallons of water a year nationwide. The average household's leaks account for more than 9,300 gallons a year. Nine percent of homes have leaks that waste 50 gallons or more per day. Fixing easily corrected household leaks can save a homeowner about 10 percent on the water bill. And if a family of four exceeds 12,000 gallons in a month, looking at a colder month such as January or February, there could be serious leaks.
The calculator prints the last two beside your own figure and does not scale the family-of-four number to your household, because EPA does not.
The three common leaks EPA names
- Worn toilet flappers. The most common silent leak in a house. Test it by putting a few drops of food coloring in the tank and waiting ten minutes without flushing; color in the bowl means the flapper is passing water. A flapper is an inexpensive part.
- Dripping faucets. EPA reports that a faucet dripping once per second wastes more than 3,000 gallons a year, and a showerhead leaking at 10 drips a minute wastes more than 500 gallons a year.
- Other leaking valves. EPA directs more complicated shower valve leaks to an experienced handyperson or a licensed plumber.
Where the line is A flapper and a faucet washer are ordinary household repairs with shutoffs right there. Anything behind a wall, anything under pressure that you cannot isolate, and anything involving a water heater's connections is in the who-to-call table.
Run the test twice a year and write both results on the meter sheet. A single reading tells you about today. Two readings a year apart tell you about a trend, which is what finds a slow leak before it finds you.
7. When something is already wet
Everything above is planning. This section is the exception, and it is short.
EPA's guidance is to dry water-damaged areas and items within 24 to 48 hours to prevent mold growth, and states that if wet or damp materials are dried within that window, in most cases mold will not grow. That is the clock you are working to.
- Stop the water. The fixture stop, or the main you labeled in Walk your house.
- Get the water out and the air moving. Within the 24 to 48 hour window.
- Find out what got wet that you cannot see. Water travels along joists and under flooring, and the wet patch is rarely the whole extent.
- Then diagnose. Not before.
The mold threshold. EPA says that if the moldy area is less than about 10 square feet, roughly a 3 foot by 3 foot patch, a homeowner can in most cases handle it. Above 10 square feet, or after a lot of water damage, EPA directs the reader to its guidance for schools and commercial buildings, which it says applies to other building types too, and in practice that is the line at which this becomes somebody else's job.
A moldy area larger than about 10 square feet, or any area with a lot of water damage, is not a job to take on yourself. Nor is anything involving sewage, which is a different category again. University of Minnesota Extension's guidance on mold starts in the same place this manual does, which is finding the water source first: cleaning mold without removing the water that fed it produces mold again.
8. See it See it
Ray and Diane Okonkwo, the 1958 ranch outside Dayton, with a finished full basement. Ray will not use a ladder.
Known, measured on a Saturday: the eave runs about 150 feet in total, and there are two downspouts. The drainage calculator gives three as the number Minnesota's figure calls for, so one to add. Both existing extensions discharge about 18 inches from the wall, against Minnesota's 4 foot minimum. On the north side the ground falls about 2 inches over 6 feet, against the published minimum of 6 inches over 6 feet. And after a storm, water sheets over the gutter edge above the porch, which is the loose section from the walk-through.
Assumed, and it is Ray's assumption: that the damp patch at the base of the north basement wall is seepage from the surface rather than groundwater. He has taped three squares of foil to the wall and dated them, so the assumption has a test running. What would settle it is the foil, in two days.
Still open, and who settles each: the loose gutter above the porch (a gutter contractor, because of the ladder answer, and they can add the third downspout in the same visit); whether the north grade can be corrected at all, because the neighbor's drive runs close on that side, which Ray can assess with a tape and a board; and whether anything behind the finished basement wall got wet, which he cannot see and which is a question for whoever opens it if it comes to that.
Their meter test. Two readings, two hours apart, with the house quiet: no change on the small dial. They wrote both readings and the zero result on the meter sheet anyway, because the value of the first test is as a baseline for the second one in six months.
Their conclusion, with its uncertainty intact: under the assumption that the damp wall is surface seepage, the cheap end of the path has three unaddressed failures on it (an extension length, a downspout count, and a grade), and the right order is to fix all three and watch for a season before considering anything larger. If the foil test says condensation instead, the work moves to Air, moisture and insulation and the grading row drops in priority.
- University of Minnesota Extension on moisture in basements: the downspout count, the 4 foot extension, the 1 inch per foot over 6 feet, and the warning about dehumidifiers.
- Kansas State Research and Extension, Dry Basements and Crawl Spaces (a PDF): the 15 foot ideal, the footing drainage study, and the warning that backfill settles.
- EPA WaterSense's Fix a Leak Week: the meter test, the published leak figures and the three common leaks.
- EPA's Brief Guide to Mold, Moisture, and Your Home: the 24 to 48 hour drying window and the 10 square foot threshold.
- Penn State Extension on controlling stormwater on your property: directing downspouts away from foundations, and what a homeowner can do about runoff on their own lot.
- Virginia Cooperative Extension on signs of subterranean termite infestation (a PDF): why wood-to-soil contact and moisture at the foundation are worth the same walk.
9. Practice Practice
Minimum: the downspout count, the extensions and one meter test, which is the Start here result. Time: about three hours, plus a rainy twenty minutes. Materials: a tape measure, a 6 foot straight board, a level, foil or plastic and tape, a hose, and a coat.
- Stand outside in a real rain and watch the house for twenty minutes. Where water goes is visible for about that long a few times a year, and nothing substitutes for it. If you cannot wait, run a hose into the gutters instead.
- Measure the eave and count the downspouts, then run the drainage calculator.
- Measure each extension's discharge distance and the grade on each elevation with the board and level. Write all of it down, even where it passes.
- Tape foil squares to any damp masonry and date them, then leave them for two days.
- Run the meter test and write both readings on the meter sheet, including a result of zero.
Two longer exercises. Run a hose test on one elevation: put a hose in the gutter for twenty minutes on a dry day and watch the ground and the basement wall inside, which isolates one part of the path from the weather. And trace a buried downspout line if you have one, by flooding it and finding where the water comes out, because a buried line that has collapsed or filled is a downspout that discharges at the foundation without appearing to.
10. Your house Your house
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every downspout discharge at least 4 feet from the wall, onto ground that falls away?
- Do you have at least one downspout per 50 feet of eave?
- Have you measured the grade rather than judged it by eye? A grade that looks fine often falls an inch over six feet.
- If something is damp, do you know which of the three sources it is, from a test rather than from an impression?
- Does the meter sheet have two readings and a result, including a result of zero?
Worked example
The Okonkwos pass on two criteria and fail on three, which is the common result on a first pass and is the point of measuring. Their meter sheet has two readings and a zero. They know their damp wall has a test running rather than a diagnosis. What they fail is the downspout count (two where three are called for), the extension length (18 inches against 4 feet) and the grade (2 inches over 6 feet against 6). All three failures are at the cheap end of the path, all three are now rows with a tier and a who, and the two that need a ladder have a contractor in the Who column rather than a blank.
Common mistakes
- Buying a product before finding the source. A dehumidifier, a sealant or a sump bought for the wrong source does nothing, and Minnesota's caution is that in a basement with moisture problems a dehumidifier may cause greater damage.
- Judging a grade by eye. Ground that looks level often falls toward the house, and the measurement takes five minutes.
- Leaving an extension at a foot or two. This is the single most common finding and one of the cheapest to fix.
- Treating a dry patch as resolved. A stain that is dry today is a stain that was wet sometime. Mark its edge and date it.
- Going up the ladder anyway. The ladder answer is a decision you made when you were not standing at the bottom of one.
- Skipping the meter test because the bill looks normal. A bill is a month of averaging. Two readings two hours apart are a measurement.
What is still unresolved
This chapter handles the part of the path you can see and reach. It does not settle what is happening at a footing drain, under a slab, behind a finished wall or inside a roof assembly. If a basement is still wet after the gutters, the extensions and the grade are right, that is a specialist's question. Humidity and condensation as an indoor air problem rather than a water-entry problem are in Air, moisture and insulation, which is also where ice dams live. Who to call for each of these is the who-to-call table.