Air, moisture and insulation
Water, air and the shell

Air, moisture and insulation: humidity, ventilation and the shell

Indoor humidity is a number you measure, condensation is a surface temperature problem, and an ice dam is a heat-loss problem. Air sealing comes before insulating.

Start here Essentials

At minimum, buy a hygrometer and get a week of readings, then measure the attic depth if you can reach it. Vapor retarders, attic ventilation, blower door testing and the Alaska zone list are Go deeper.

  1. Buy a hygrometer and put it in the room that feels worst. EPA prices a moisture or humidity meter at $10 to $50 at a hardware store (humidity).
  2. Read it morning and evening for a week and write the numbers down on the log.
  3. If it reads above 60 percent, run the bath and kitchen fans and read again (indoor air).
  4. Look at the attic insulation depth and compare it with the DOE table for your zone (insulation).

Minimum time: about 20 minutes, spread over a week. Done when: seven dated humidity readings are written down, and the attic depth, or the word unknown, is written beside the DOE figure for your zone.

1. Humidity is a number you measure Understand

Most household moisture advice is written as though humidity were a feeling. It is a number, it costs about as much to measure as a pizza, and measuring it turns four or five vague complaints into one quantity you can act on.

Relative humidity is how much water vapor the air holds as a percentage of what it could hold at that temperature. The second half of that sentence is the part that matters later: warm air can hold more water than cold air, so the same amount of moisture is a higher relative humidity in a cold room than in a warm one. That single fact explains condensation, ice dams and most of the puzzling moisture in a house.

EPA's published range: keep indoor humidity below 60 percent relative humidity, ideally between 30 and 50 percent, measured with a moisture or humidity meter that EPA prices at $10 to $50 at hardware stores.

Test it One reading tells you almost nothing. A week of morning and evening readings tells you whether the problem is constant, daily or weather-driven, which is three different problems with three different fixes. Write them on the log with dates. Put a second hygrometer in a basement or a problem room if you have one, because a house can be 42 percent upstairs and 68 percent in the basement on the same afternoon.

Where indoor moisture comes from

A household generates a surprising amount of water vapor: cooking, showering, laundry, dishwashing, breathing, houseplants, and in some houses an unsealed crawl space or a basement with a damp floor. University of Minnesota Extension's guidance on controlling moisture problems covers these sources and the relationship between indoor humidity and condensation on cold surfaces.

The three strategies against it come down to the same three, in this order: produce less, remove it at the source, or warm the surface it is condensing on. A dehumidifier is a fourth option and it is usually the last one rather than the first, for the reasons in Keeping water out.

2. Condensation

Condensation is not a weather event. It is humid air meeting a surface that is cold enough, and both halves of that are things you can change.

Physical principle Air cooled far enough can no longer hold the water it is carrying, and the water comes out onto whatever cooled it. The temperature at which that happens for a given air is its dew point. So condensation appears exactly where a house has its coldest surfaces: window glass, the corners of exterior walls, cold water pipes, the inside of a closet on an exterior wall, and the floor of an unheated room.

Which means a wipe is not a fix. If you dry a window every morning, you have a daily task rather than a resolved problem, and the moisture is also condensing where you cannot see it.

Where it showsWhat it is telling youWhat usually changes it
Window glass in winterIndoor humidity is high relative to the glass temperatureLess moisture indoors, more ventilation, or a warmer glass surface
Corners of exterior walls, behind furnitureThose surfaces are colder than the rest of the wall, often from a gap in insulation or air leakageAir sealing and insulation; moving the furniture off the wall helps a little
Cold water pipesThe pipe is below the dew point of the room airPipe insulation, which is cheap, or lower humidity
Inside closets on exterior wallsStill air plus a cold wallLeave the door ajar, move things off the wall, and treat the wall's coldness
On a basement floor or wall in summerWarm humid air meeting cool masonryThe foil test in Keeping water out first, to tell this from seepage

The last row is the important one, because it is where condensation and water entry look identical and have opposite fixes. Tape foil squares to the wall before deciding anything.

3. Ice dams, and the winter version of the same problem

An ice dam is a ridge of ice at the edge of a roof that stops meltwater draining, so the water backs up under the roof covering and into the house.

University of Minnesota Extension describes the mechanism: heat escaping into the roof deck melts snow on the upper roof, the meltwater runs down to the eave, which is colder because there is no heated space beneath it, and refreezes. The dam grows, and the water pooling behind it finds a way in.

It is a heat-loss problem That is the whole diagnosis. An ice dam is not a roof defect and not a gutter defect. It is heat leaving the house into the roof structure, which makes it the same problem as a cold-corner condensation patch, seen from outside in winter.

What follows from that:

  • Removing the ice treats the symptom and can damage the roof covering in the process. It may be the right emergency action when water is coming in; it is not a fix.
  • Heating cables manage the symptom too, at a running cost, and they do not address the heat loss.
  • The lasting fix is air sealing and insulation at the ceiling plane, which is Minnesota's conclusion and which is the next section of this chapter.

Which is why the ice dam watch on your calendar is an observation rather than a job. After a lasting snow followed by a thaw, look at the eaves. Ice there is telling you where your ceiling plane is leaking heat, and it is information you can only collect a few times a year.

Caution

Getting onto a snow-covered roof to clear ice is outside what this manual asks of anybody. If water is coming in and something has to be done now, that is a call to a contractor who does it, not a ladder in January.

4. Insulation, and the order of operations

Two layers, two jobs, and one order. How the systems work introduces the distinction; here it becomes a measurement and a number.

Air sealing comes first

DOE's Energy Saver Guide puts caulking and sealing first and states plainly that after you complete air sealing, consider whether you need to add insulation. The guide says air leaks are among the greatest sources of energy loss in a home, that caulking, sealing and weatherstripping all seams, cracks and openings to the outside is one of the quickest money- and energy-saving tasks, and that by sealing uncontrolled air leaks you can save 10 to 20 percent on your heating and cooling bills.

Its own list of where to air seal in a home is worth copying onto a sheet: plumbing and utility access, ducts, sill plates, outlets and switches, water and furnace flues, recessed lights, the attic entrance, chimney flashing, dropped ceilings, door frames and window frames.

DOE also gives a way to find leaks: on a windy day, carefully hold a lit incense stick or a smoke pen next to windows, doors, electrical boxes, plumbing fixtures, outlets, ceiling fixtures, attic hatches and other suspect places, and where the smoke stream travels horizontally you have found a leak.

Limits

Adding insulation over an unsealed ceiling plane does not deliver what the package says, because air is carrying heat and moisture straight past it, and in a cold climate that moisture ends up condensing in the insulation or on the roof deck. DOE's order is air sealing first, then insulation, and it is an order rather than a preference. This matters most in exactly the house where somebody is about to add attic insulation to stop ice dams.

R-value and the DOE table

DOE defines R-value as a measure of insulation's resistance to heat flow, higher being more insulating, dependent on the type of insulation and its thickness, and printed on the packaging or on the paper backing of rolled insulation.

Here is DOE's table of recommended total R-values for new or existing wood-framed houses, by climate zone, as published in the 2022 Energy Saver Guide. The guide credits the table to ENERGY STAR and notes that the recommendations are cost-effective levels based on local fuel and materials costs and weather conditions, so they may differ from current local building codes. Read your zone off the 2012 IECC map described in Your own calendar.

Climate zoneUninsulated attic3 to 4 inches of existing attic insulationUninsulated floor
1R30 to R49R19 to R38R13
2R49 to R60R38 to R49R13
3R49 to R60R38 to R49R19
4 except marineR60R49R19
4 marine, and 5R60R49R30
6R60R49R30
7 and 8R60R49R38

The guide's wall columns use the abbreviation CI for continuous insulation applied to the exterior of the wall assembly just inside the cladding, and its wall recommendations apply when exterior siding is being removed, which is a renovation decision rather than a maintenance one. Zone 1 includes Hawaii, Guam, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, and the guide lists Alaska's zones borough by borough.

Measuring what you have

Put a ruler or a tape into the insulation at several places away from the hatch, down to the ceiling drywall, and read the depth. Write down the depth, the type if you can tell (loose fill, batts, or a mix) and whether it is even. Depth alone does not give you an R-value, because different materials differ per inch, but it tells you which column of the table you are in and whether you are close to the recommendation or nowhere near it.

What to note while you are up there: insulation pushed aside or missing at the eaves, gaps around the hatch, recessed light fixtures buried in insulation (which may be a fire question depending on the fixture type and is worth asking an electrician about), bath fan ducts ending in the attic rather than outside, and daylight anywhere.

ENERGY STAR's figure for the whole package is bounded and worth quoting exactly: sealing air leaks and adding insulation can help your home be more comfortable and energy efficient and provide up to a 10 percent saving on your annual energy bills. ENERGY STAR also notes that not every insulation is designed for every part of the house, which is the reason to ask what goes where rather than buying what is on the shelf.

5. Indoor air

EPA names three basic strategies to improve indoor air quality: source control, improved ventilation and air cleaning. EPA adds that source control is also a more cost-efficient approach than increasing ventilation, because increasing ventilation can increase energy costs.

That order is the useful part. Before buying a machine, ask what is producing the thing you want removed and whether it can be produced less, vented at the source, or stored somewhere else.

Filters

EPA's guide to air cleaners recommends selecting a furnace or heating and cooling filter rated at least MERV 13, or as high as your system will accommodate. MERV is the rating scale for how much of what size particle a filter captures, and higher numbers capture more.

Limits

The second half of EPA's sentence does real work. A filter too restrictive for the blower is a heating and cooling problem rather than an air quality improvement: it can reduce airflow enough to affect comfort and, over time, the equipment. What your system will accommodate is not something you can settle by reading. Check the equipment's own documentation, or ask the technician at the annual service in Heating, cooling and hot water, and write the answer on the systems sheet so the next person buying filters knows.

Portable air cleaners

EPA's guidance is to choose a portable air cleaner whose clean air delivery rate, or CADR, suits the room size: the higher the CADR, the larger the area it can serve. Three caveats EPA states and which are routinely left out of product descriptions:

  • The CADR chart assumes an 8-foot ceiling, so a room with a higher ceiling needs a higher CADR.
  • The CADR rating system is for particles only.
  • There is no widely used performance rating for air cleaners or filters designed to remove gases.

So a CADR number answers a question about particles in a room of a stated height, and nothing else. For gases and odors, EPA's first strategy applies: find the source.

Ventilation

The bath fan and the range hood are the house's source-control ventilation, and the two things worth knowing about them are whether they discharge outside (checked from the ground in Walk your house) and whether they run long enough. Moisture leaves a bathroom over several minutes after a shower, not during it, so a fan switched off with the light is doing part of the job.

6. Safety in a tightened house

Air sealing is tier 4 work with a tier 2 edge, and this section is the edge.

A house that has been sealed is a house with less uncontrolled air movement, which is the point. In a house with fuel-burning appliances, that air movement was also supplying combustion air and, in some arrangements, helping flues draft. University of Minnesota Extension's guidance on keeping a home warm and safe in winter covers the general territory, and CPSC's guidance is the specific one: have the heating system professionally inspected and serviced annually, with the inspector also checking chimneys and flues for blockages, corrosion, partial and complete disconnections and loose connections.

Caution

If your house burns any fuel, the air sealing work in this chapter belongs in the same year as the annual combustion inspection in Alarms, vents and tests, and the CO alarms belong in place before either. CPSC's own line is that an alarm is no substitute for proper use and upkeep of appliances that can produce CO, which cuts both ways: the alarm is not the answer, and it is also not optional.

One more interaction, for an older house. Attic and crawl space work in a home built before 1978 raises the lead paint question, and so does any disturbance of painted surfaces elsewhere. Alarms, vents and tests settles that before anybody sands, scrapes or demolishes anything.

Go deeper

Why a dehumidifier in a wet basement can make things worse

University of Minnesota Extension states that dehumidification is not a permanent or complete solution and that in a basement with moisture problems it may cause greater damage, by drawing moisture in faster and causing efflorescence and spalling of the concrete. The mechanism is that lowering the humidity of the basement air increases the rate at which water moves through the masonry toward it. A dehumidifier is a reasonable tool for a dry basement with humid air; it is the wrong tool where water is coming through a wall, and the foil test in Keeping water out tells you which you have.

Vapor retarders, and why the answer depends on the climate

A vapor retarder slows water vapor diffusing through an assembly. Which side of the assembly it belongs on, and whether one belongs there at all, depends on which direction vapor is usually driving, which is a climate question: broadly inward in a hot humid climate and outward in a cold one, with mixed climates genuinely mixed. This is an area where general advice has done real damage, because a retarder on the wrong side can trap moisture in an assembly. It is a question for somebody who designs assemblies in your climate, and it is outside what a maintenance manual can settle.

Attic ventilation and the arguments about it

Attic ventilation is debated among people who build and research buildings, and the debate is mostly about what the ventilation is for in a particular assembly: removing moisture, keeping the deck cold to limit ice dams, or neither in an assembly designed to be unvented. The published advice differs because the publications are addressing different assemblies. What is not in dispute is what comes before it: air sealing the ceiling plane, so that household moisture is not being delivered into the attic in the first place. Do that part, and take the ventilation question to somebody looking at your actual roof.

Blower door testing and a professional energy audit

A blower door depressurizes the house with a calibrated fan and measures how much air leaks in, which turns air sealing from guesswork into a number before and after. A professional energy audit usually includes one, often with infrared imaging to find where the leaks and the missing insulation are. DOE's Energy Saver Guide treats an audit as the step that produces a prioritized list of projects. It costs money, and the case for it is strongest on an older house where you are about to spend a lot on the envelope and want to spend it in the right places.

The Alaska zone list

DOE's guide lists Alaska's climate zones borough by borough rather than by a map region, from zone 5 in Ketchikan Gateway, Prince of Wales Outer Ketchikan and Sitka, through zone 6 in Haines, Juneau, Kodiak Island, Skagway-Hoonah-Angoon and Wrangell-Petersburg, to zone 7 and zone 8 across most of the interior and the north. If you are in Alaska, read your borough off the guide's list rather than off the national map.

7. See it See it

Fictional example

Marisol Reyes in Austin and Odette Baptiste outside Burlington, with the same hygrometer exercise and opposite results.

Marisol. Hot and humid, IECC zone 2, slab on grade, attic with blown insulation, heat pump. Her week of readings: 58 to 64 percent, highest in the afternoons, consistently above EPA's 60 percent ceiling in the worst room. Her condensation shows up in summer on the cold-water pipes in the laundry closet and on the supply registers, which is the hot-humid pattern rather than the winter-window pattern. Her attic depth measures about 6 inches of blown insulation, against DOE's R49 to R60 for zone 2 on an uninsulated attic and R38 to R49 over 3 to 4 inches of existing insulation, so she is in the second column and short of it.

Odette. Very cold, zone 6, 1920s farmhouse, oil boiler with radiators, a wood stove, a crawl space under part of the house. Her week of readings: 28 to 34 percent in January, which is below EPA's ideal range rather than above it, and which is what a leaky old house does in a cold winter. Her moisture shows up as window condensation on the coldest mornings and as ice at two eaves after the first lasting snow.

Known: seven dated readings each, both attic and crawl space depths measured, and in Odette's case photographs of which two eaves iced.

Assumed, and it is Odette's: that the two iced eaves correspond to the two rooms with the worst drafts, which is a hypothesis about where her ceiling plane leaks rather than a finding. What would settle it is a blower door test with infrared, or an afternoon in the attic with DOE's incense-stick method on a windy day.

Still open, with who settles each: whether Marisol's attic can take more insulation without air sealing first, which it cannot, so the sealing work comes before any insulation quote; what MERV her heat pump's blower will accept, which is a question for the technician at her March service; and whether Odette's crawl space is contributing moisture to the house, which the foil test will begin to answer.

The conclusion each one drew, with its uncertainty intact. Marisol: under these readings her house is above EPA's ceiling, the ventilation step comes before any machine, and the attic work is sealing first and insulation second. Odette: her humidity is low, her problem is heat loss rather than moisture production, and the ice at the eaves is the most useful piece of evidence she will get all year about where it is leaving.

8. Practice Practice

Minimum: a hygrometer and seven dated readings, which is most of the Start here result. Time: about 20 minutes of actual work spread over a week, plus an hour in the attic. Materials: a hygrometer ($10 to $50 per EPA), a tape measure or ruler, a flashlight, and incense or a smoke pen for the leak test.

  1. Put the hygrometer in the worst room and read it morning and evening for a week, writing each reading with its date on the log.
  2. Measure the attic insulation depth at four places away from the hatch and note the type and whether it is even.
  3. Do DOE's incense test on a windy day at windows, doors, outlets, ceiling fixtures and the attic hatch, and mark the leaks with tape as you find them.
  4. Write your zone's DOE figure beside your measured depth so the gap is a number rather than an impression.
  5. Add the air sealing jobs you found to the ranked job list, tier 4, with the ones you can do yourself separated from the ones you cannot reach.
Go deeper

Two longer exercises. Run a second hygrometer in the basement or crawl space for the same week and compare, which often shows that the house has two humidity problems rather than one. And photograph the eaves after the first lasting snow and a thaw, from the same spots each year, which builds a record of where heat is leaving that no single winter can give you.

9. Your house Your house

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Do you have seven dated readings rather than an impression of the humidity?
  • Can you say whether your condensation is a moisture problem, a cold-surface problem, or both, and on what evidence?
  • Is your attic depth written as a number beside the DOE figure for your zone and the right column of the table?
  • Is air sealing ahead of insulation on your job list, rather than behind it?
  • If anything in the house burns fuel, is the annual combustion inspection on the calendar in the same year as any sealing work?

Worked example

Marisol passes on all five: seven readings, a summer cold-surface pattern she can describe, six inches measured against DOE's second column for zone 2, sealing ahead of insulating on her list, and no combustion equipment to worry about. Odette passes on four and is thin on the second: she knows her ice dams are a heat-loss problem, but she has not established whether her winter window condensation is unusually high for her humidity level or just what a 1920s window does at 32 percent and 10 degrees outside. That is a question a window's surface temperature would answer, and it is on her list as a row rather than a conclusion.

Common mistakes

  • Wiping the window. A daily task is not a fix, and the moisture is also condensing where you cannot see it.
  • Insulating before air sealing. DOE's order is an order. Insulation over an unsealed ceiling plane underperforms and can collect moisture.
  • Buying a dehumidifier for a wet wall. Minnesota's caution is specific: in a basement with moisture problems it may cause greater damage.
  • Fitting the highest MERV filter the slot takes. EPA's recommendation ends with "or as high as your system will accommodate", and the second clause is a real limit.
  • Reading a CADR number as an air quality guarantee. It is particles only, at an assumed 8-foot ceiling, with no equivalent rating for gases.
  • Clearing ice off a roof as the plan. It is a symptom measure at best and a roof-damaging one at worst.

What is still unresolved

This chapter gives you a humidity number, a depth and a target. It does not tell you what your walls contain, whether your assembly wants a vapor retarder and on which side, or whether your attic should be vented, all of which depend on the assembly and the climate and belong with somebody looking at your house. It does not settle what MERV your blower will take, which is the technician's answer in Heating, cooling and hot water. And where water is entering rather than condensing, the chapter is Keeping water out, which comes first.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does this chapter call an ice dam a heat-loss problem rather than a roof problem?
Because the mechanism starts inside. Heat escaping into the roof deck melts snow on the upper roof; the meltwater reaches the colder eave and refreezes. The roof covering and the gutters are where it shows, not where it comes from, which is why Minnesota's lasting fix is air sealing and insulation at the ceiling plane.
Your bedroom window streams with water every winter morning and your hygrometer reads 55 percent. What are your options?
Three, and they can be combined: less moisture produced or more removed at the source (fans running longer, drying laundry elsewhere), more ventilation, or a warmer glass surface. 55 percent is inside EPA's below-60 ceiling but above its 30 to 50 ideal, and in a cold climate the glass is cold enough that the ideal range is where you want to be.
Why does EPA's filter recommendation have two halves?
Because the first half is about air quality and the second is about the equipment. At least MERV 13 is the air quality target; or as high as your system will accommodate is the limit, because a filter too restrictive for the blower reduces airflow and becomes a heating and cooling problem. The documentation or the technician answers the second half.
(Go deeper) Why can a vapor retarder on the wrong side of an assembly cause harm?
Because it slows vapor moving in one direction, and if that is the direction the assembly needs to dry in, moisture is trapped inside it. Which direction vapor usually drives is a climate question, broadly inward in hot humid climates and outward in cold ones, with mixed climates genuinely mixed. It is a question for somebody who designs assemblies in your climate.
You get ice dams every winter. A contractor offers to add 12 inches of blown insulation to your attic, and a second offers heating cables along the eaves. What do you ask for?
The right direction and it skips the step DOE puts first. Insulation blown over an unsealed ceiling plane lets warm moist air keep moving past it into the attic, which both reduces what the insulation delivers and puts moisture where you do not want it.
This is the order DOE states and Minnesota's conclusion about ice dams points at. Asking for the air sealing itemized separately also makes the two quotes comparable, which is what Hiring help is about: a quote for insulation alone and a quote for sealing plus insulation are not the same scope.
Cables manage the symptom at a running cost and leave the heat loss doing everything else it does, including costing you money on every cold day. They can be a reasonable interim measure on a roof that cannot be fixed this year; they are not the fix.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.