Heating, cooling and hot water: what you do and what the technician does
You change filters, keep clearances, read dates and book the service. The technician opens the cabinet and touches the gas, the refrigerant, the flue and the wiring.
Start here Essentials
At minimum, take charge of the filter and book the service. Heat pumps in cold weather, bleeding radiators, combustion analysis, tankless descaling and expansion tanks are all Go deeper.
- Find your filter size and buy three, so the next two changes need no shopping trip (filters).
- Change it and write the date on the log.
- Set a monthly reminder to look at it, which is ENERGY STAR's interval.
- Book the annual heating service and write the two things it must cover on the log (the annual service).
- Check the water heater's temperature setting against the published 120 degrees Fahrenheit (hot water).
Minimum time: about an hour, plus a phone call. Done when: a dated filter change is on the log, a service appointment is booked or a date to book it is written down, and the water heater's setting is recorded.
1. The division of labor Understand
This chapter is organized around one sentence, and everything in it follows from that sentence.
You change filters, keep clearances, read gauges and dates, and book the service. The technician opens the cabinet and touches the gas, the refrigerant, the flue and the electrical connections.
| Item | Yours | The technician's | Published interval |
|---|---|---|---|
| Air filter | Look at it, change it, write the date | Tell you what MERV the blower will take | Check monthly; change at a minimum every 3 months (ENERGY STAR) |
| Clearances around the equipment | Keep them clear, measure once | Say whether the clearance is adequate for this appliance | At least 3 feet from heat sources (US Fire Administration) |
| Burners and heat exchanger | Nothing | Inspect and service | Yearly (ENERGY STAR; US Fire Administration) |
| Flue and chimney | Look for soot or staining from outside the cabinet | Check for blockages, corrosion, partial and complete disconnections and loose connections | Each year, by a professional (CPSC; US Fire Administration) |
| Gas connection | Nothing, except knowing where the shutoff is | All of it | At the annual service |
| Refrigerant | Nothing | All of it | At the annual service |
| Ducts | Seal accessible joints with mastic or metal-backed foil tape | Assess and seal the rest; measure leakage | No published interval; the figure is up to 20 percent efficiency improvement (ENERGY STAR) |
| Water heater temperature | Read it, set it, record both | Confirm it at a service visit | 120 degrees Fahrenheit (DOE; University of Missouri Extension) |
| Water heater flush | Yours, or hand it over | Theirs if you prefer | Monthly in hard water to once a year elsewhere (University of Missouri Extension) |
| Relief valve test | Yours, with the failure mode understood, or hand it over | Theirs if you prefer, and theirs if it will not reseat | Listed as a homeowner check (University of Georgia Extension) |
That line is not a statement about anybody's competence. It is where the published guidance puts the boundary, and it has two useful properties. It is unambiguous, so you never have to decide in the moment whether something is yours. And the half that is yours is cheap, frequent and high-value: a monthly look at a filter and a dated record of when the service happened are, between them, most of what a householder can actually do for this equipment.
This chapter gives no instruction for opening a sealed combustion cabinet, touching a gas or propane connection, working on refrigerant, or working on a water heater's gas or electrical connections. What it does is tell you what to look at, what a reading or a symptom means, what to ask the technician to cover, and who does the rest. The who-to-call table names the trade for each and where a license is verified.
One more framing, which saves money. Most of the published guidance in this chapter is about the equipment lasting rather than about the house being comfortable. A filter is there to protect the blower and the coil. A service visit is there to catch things while they are cheap. The comfort is downstream.
2. Filters
ENERGY STAR's maintenance checklist gives the interval precisely, and it is worth reading as three separate instructions:
- Check the air filter every month, especially during heavy-use months, which it names as winter and summer.
- If it looks dirty after a month, change it.
- At a minimum, change it every 3 months.
So the monthly item is a look, not a change. That distinction matters because it makes the monthly habit trivially cheap: pull the filter, hold it up to a light, put it back or put a new one in. Thirty seconds.
Why it matters. ENERGY STAR states that a dirty filter slows airflow, makes the system work harder, and lets dust build up in the system, leading to expensive maintenance and early system failure. That is a published link between a household habit and the life of a piece of equipment, and it is about as direct as the sources in this manual get.
Finding the size
Three numbers, printed on the cardboard edge of the filter you take out: width, height and thickness, in inches, like 20 by 25 by 1. Write them on the systems sheet, not on a scrap of paper. If the old filter has no printing, measure it, and note that the printed size and the actual size often differ by a fraction, which is normal.
Where the filter lives varies: a slot beside the indoor equipment, a grille in a wall or ceiling with a hinged door, or sometimes both in a system with two returns. A system with two return filters and a householder who only knows about one is common.
MERV, and its limit
EPA recommends selecting a filter rated at least MERV 13, or as high as your system will accommodate. The second clause is the limit, and Air, moisture and insulation covers why: a filter too restrictive for the blower reduces airflow, which is a heating and cooling problem rather than an air quality improvement.
Ask the authority What your system will accommodate is in the equipment's documentation or in the technician's head. Ask at the annual service and write the answer on the systems sheet, so that whoever buys filters next is buying the right ones.
Houses with no ducts have no central filter. A boiler with radiators, electric baseboard and mini-splits all have either nothing to change or their own washable filters on the maker's interval. Write "no central filter" on the sheet rather than hunting for one every year.
3. The annual service, and what it must cover
Two published sources converge here, and together they give you a specification rather than a vague appointment.
ENERGY STAR says to tune up the heating and cooling equipment yearly.
CPSC says to have the heating system professionally inspected and serviced annually, and adds what the inspection should include: the inspector should also check chimneys and flues for blockages, corrosion, partial and complete disconnections, and loose connections.
That second sentence is the one to be able to quote. It is the difference between a technician changing a filter and taking a reading, and a technician looking at the path the products of combustion take to leave your house. The US Fire Administration says the same thing from the fire side: maintain heating equipment and chimneys by having them cleaned and inspected each year by a professional.
Booking it
Book it out of season. Every technician in your area is busy during the first cold week, and an appointment booked in August is an appointment; one requested in November is a queue position. Your upkeep calendar puts the row before your first freeze month for exactly this reason.
What to write down
Before the visit, write the two coverage sentences on the log so you can say them. After the visit, write down:
- The date, the company and the technician's name.
- Anything they said about the equipment's condition, in their words rather than your summary.
- Anything they recommended, with a price if they gave one, and whether you agreed to it.
- Whether the chimney and flue were checked, and what they found.
- The MERV rating the system will take, which is the question to ask while they are standing there.
Those notes are the service history that What wears out and when says outranks any published service life figure. They take five minutes a year and in ten years they are the most valuable thing in your house file.
4. Ducts
ENERGY STAR gives a bounded figure for duct work: sealing and insulating ducts can improve the efficiency of your heating and cooling system by as much as 20 percent, and sometimes much more. It says to start with ducts that run through the attic, crawlspace, unheated basement or garage, and to use duct sealant (mastic) or metal-backed foil tape.
Two things are doing work in that guidance. The location matters because a duct leaking inside the conditioned space is losing air into the house, which is wasteful but not lost; a duct leaking in an attic is delivering heated air to the outdoors. And the materials matter because the product named duct tape is not the recommended material for sealing ducts; mastic or metal-backed foil tape is.
How far a householder can get with this depends on access. Accessible duct joints in a basement or garage are within reach for many people. Ducts buried in insulation in an attic, or inaccessible runs inside framing, are a contractor's job, and so is any assessment of how leaky the system is overall, which is measured rather than guessed.
Order of operations ENERGY STAR also says to address the big air leaks in the house and the duct system before investing in a new system, because, in its words, sometimes these are the real sources of problems rather than the equipment. That is a published instruction to fix the cheap thing before buying the expensive one, and it is worth holding onto when a contractor is quoting a replacement for a system that does not keep the house comfortable.
5. When to stop repairing
ENERGY STAR gives a trigger: if the heating and cooling equipment is more than 10 years old or not keeping the house comfortable, have it evaluated by a professional heating and cooling contractor.
Note what that is and is not. It is a trigger for an evaluation, not an instruction to replace, and it is the same shape as the service life triggers in What wears out and when. A 14 year old furnace that works is not a furnace to remove; it is a furnace to have an opinion on and a figure set aside for.
The arithmetic, when the question becomes real, is in the repair-or-replace calculator: the repair cost over the extra years it is expected to buy, against the replacement cost over the replacement's expected life. The number that settles it is the extra years, and that number comes from the technician. Ask for it in writing with the repair quote.
The common rule that you should replace when a repair costs more than half a new one has no published basis we found, and this manual does not use it. It is also structurally odd: it compares a repair's price with a replacement's price while ignoring how long each one lasts, which is the whole question. Cost per remaining year compares like with like, and it says out loud which estimate it depends on.
ENERGY STAR also notes that replacing old equipment with certified equipment can cut an annual energy bill by nearly $140, depending on where you live. That figure is attached to a specific comparison and a stated dependency, and it belongs in the arithmetic as one input rather than as a reason.
6. Hot water
Four published items, and one that needs careful handling.
Temperature
Set it to 120 degrees Fahrenheit. DOE's Energy Saver Guide gives that figure and describes it as a temperature considered safe for most of the population. University of Missouri Extension gives the same figure, describing it as midway between low and the next setting on a typical tank, and notes that a dishwasher with its own internal booster heater does not require a higher tank setting. Check your dishwasher's manual for instructions specific to your model.
Two sources agreeing on a number is as solid as this manual's figures get. Record the setting you found and the setting you left it at on the log, because the next person to look at it will want to know whether it drifted or somebody changed it.
Sediment and flushing
Missouri Extension describes the mechanism: sediment and scale, meaning dirt and mineral deposits, build up inside the tank, and the remedy is periodically flushing water from the tank. The interval depends on water hardness, from monthly in hard-water areas to once a year elsewhere.
So the first question is how hard your water is, and the answer comes from your water utility's annual report or, on a well, from a water test. The service date calculator takes the hardness answer and gives you the next date on the matching interval.
UGA's two water heater checks
University of Georgia Extension's home maintenance checklist lists two items for a water heater, and the parenthesis in the first one is part of the source:
- Inspect the water heater for leaks, corrosion and proper operation (you may opt to have a plumber do this), and inspect the flue assembly on a gas water heater.
- Test the pressure and temperature relief valve for proper operation.
The first is a look, and the flue is looked at rather than opened. The second needs its own treatment.
The relief valve, handled honestly
The temperature and pressure relief valve is a safety device that opens if the tank's pressure or temperature goes too high. Testing it means lifting its lever so that it discharges hot water down a pipe, then letting it reseat.
Here is the failure mode, stated plainly, because the sources recommend the test and the risk is real. A valve that has not been operated in years may not reseat after you lift it. If it does not, it will keep discharging hot water until somebody shuts the water off, which means knowing where your water heater's cold inlet shutoff is before you touch the lever and having a plumber's number to hand. The discharge is scalding hot. If you would rather not take that on, this is a legitimate and common choice: put it on the technician's or plumber's list instead, which is what UGA's own parenthesis contemplates for the first check.
If you do test it: know where the cold inlet shutoff is, know the main shutoff, have a plumber's number, keep hands and feet clear of the discharge pipe's outlet, and lift the lever briefly rather than holding it open. Write the date and the result on the log either way, including "put on the technician's list" as a result.
Other things worth knowing
- A rotten egg smell in the hot water only comes from the anode rod reacting with sulfate in the water, per Penn State Extension's drinking water guidance. Penn State also notes that removing the anode rod may void the heater's warranty, which makes this a conversation with a plumber rather than a weekend project.
- Rust at the base of the tank is different from a damp fitting above it. The first can be the tank; the second is usually a connection. A plumber tells them apart, and the distinction decides whether you are buying a part or a water heater.
- The three types (tank, tankless and heat pump water heater) have different upkeep: a tankless unit has descaling rather than flushing, on the maker's interval; a heat pump water heater has an air filter and a condensate path as well as a tank. ENERGY STAR's water heaters page covers what distinguishes the certified types.
- A drip pan with a drain under a tank over a finished floor is the cheap part that changes what a failure costs, as What wears out and when describes.
7. Combustion, and the handoff
Anything that burns fuel produces combustion products that have to leave the house through a flue or a chimney. When that path is blocked, corroded or disconnected, the products come into the house instead, and one of them is carbon monoxide.
Backdrafting is the word for combustion products coming back down a flue into the house instead of going up it, and it can be caused by a blockage, by a disconnection, or by the house being depressurized by something else, such as a powerful exhaust fan. It is one of the reasons the sealing work in Air, moisture and insulation belongs in the same year as the combustion inspection.
What a householder does here is short: keep the area around the equipment clear, look for soot or staining around a vent or an appliance, notice a flame that should be blue and is yellow and lazy, and book the inspection. What a householder does not do is open a flue, inspect a heat exchanger, or adjust a burner.
The rest of this subject, the alarms, the generators, the clearances and the chimney, is Alarms, vents and tests, and CPSC's sentence belongs here as the handoff: an alarm is no substitute for proper use and upkeep of appliances that can produce CO.
Heat pumps in cold weather, and what the backup is doing
A heat pump moves heat rather than making it, taking it from outdoor air, and there is less heat available as the air gets colder. Output per unit of electricity falls with the temperature, which is why cold-climate installations have a backup heat source, usually electric resistance elements, that takes over below a set temperature. If your bills jump in the coldest month, the backup is probably why, and the questions to ask the installer are what the backup is and at what outdoor temperature it engages.
Boilers and radiators
A hot-water boiler system circulates water through radiators or baseboard. Air collects at the high points and stops circulation to that emitter, which is why a radiator cold at the top and warm at the bottom is the classic symptom and why bleeding it, releasing the air through a small valve, is the classic household remedy. Systems differ in how they are filled and pressurized, and a system that needs bleeding often is a system losing water somewhere, which is a question for the technician rather than a monthly habit.
Mini-splits, evaporative coolers and window units
Mini-split indoor heads have washable filters behind the front panel, on the maker's interval; the outdoor unit and the refrigerant lines are the technician's. Evaporative coolers, common in hot-dry climates, work by evaporating water and need their pads and water system maintained on the maker's schedule, and they are a different machine from an air conditioner rather than a cheaper one. Window and portable air conditioners have their own washable filters and drain paths, and their upkeep is in the manual that came with them.
What a technician's combustion analysis measures
A combustion analyzer samples the flue gas and reports things like oxygen, carbon monoxide, flue gas temperature and efficiency, which together say whether the appliance is burning cleanly and venting properly. You do not need to interpret the numbers. What is worth doing is asking whether the technician performed one and asking for the printout or the figures, written on the log, because a series of them over years is a record of a trend rather than a snapshot.
Tankless descaling, and expansion tanks
A tankless heater's heat exchanger scales up in hard water, and the maker specifies a descaling procedure and interval. There is no published national figure for it, so the manual is the authority. An expansion tank is a small vessel on the cold supply that absorbs the pressure rise as water in a closed system heats; whether your system needs one, and whether yours is working, is a plumber's question. Both of these go on the systems sheet as facts about your house rather than as tasks.
What high efficiency means on a label
Efficiency ratings for heating and cooling equipment are set by test procedures under DOE's standards program, which covers more than 70 products representing about 90 percent of home energy use. A high-efficiency label means the equipment performs better than the federal minimum under a defined test, which is a real statement and a narrow one. Choosing and keeping appliances works through what a label settles and what your own rate settles.
Matching the flushing interval to a hardness figure
Missouri Extension's interval runs from monthly in hard water to once a year elsewhere, which is a wide range that your own water's hardness narrows. On a public system, the utility's annual water quality report usually gives hardness. On a well, a water test does, and Alarms, vents and tests covers the annual test EPA recommends. Write the figure on the systems sheet and then set the interval once rather than re-deciding every year.
8. See it See it
Ray and Diane Okonkwo, the 1958 ranch outside Dayton: gas furnace and central air conditioner both from 2009, gas tank water heater from 2016, public water, finished basement. About two hours a month between them.
Known. The filter is a 20 by 25 by 1 in a slot beside the furnace, and the old one was gray and matted, which is more than a month's worth. The water heater's dial was set between the factory mark and the next step up; they moved it to 120 degrees and wrote both settings down. Their water utility's annual report gives a hardness figure, which puts them toward the annual end of Missouri Extension's flushing range rather than the monthly end.
Assumed, and it is Ray's: that the furnace has had no service since 2009, because there are no stickers after that one. That is an inference from an absence, and it is labeled as one. What would settle it is the company named on the 2009 sticker, who may have records.
Still open, with who settles each: the furnace's condition at seventeen years, which the technician's inspection answers and which ENERGY STAR's over-10-years trigger says to ask about; what MERV the blower will take, which is a question for the same visit; and whether to test the relief valve themselves, which they have decided against.
What they did about the relief valve. Diane read the caution, located the cold inlet shutoff, and decided she would rather not be the one holding the lever in a finished basement. The row on the ranked job list reads "relief valve test: on the plumber's list at the next visit", with a who and a date. That is a completed decision rather than a skipped step, and UGA's own parenthesis about opting for a plumber is the reason it is a legitimate one.
Their conclusion, with its uncertainty intact. Under the assumption that the furnace has gone seventeen years without service, the annual visit is the highest-value hour anyone will spend on their equipment this year, and the two sentences they wrote on the log before booking it are what turns it from a filter change into an inspection that covers the flue.
- ENERGY STAR's heating and cooling maintenance checklist: the filter intervals, the yearly tune-up, the duct sealing figure, the over-10-years trigger and the instruction to fix the leaks before buying equipment.
- CPSC's carbon monoxide questions and answers: the annual professional inspection, and the sentence about what it must cover on chimneys and flues.
- University of Missouri Extension on water heaters (a PDF): the 120 degree setting, the sediment mechanism and the hardness-dependent flushing interval.
- University of Georgia Extension's home maintenance checklist (a PDF): the two water heater checks, including the parenthesis about opting for a plumber.
- Penn State Extension on common drinking water problems: the rotten egg odor in hot water only, the anode rod, and the warranty note.
- ENERGY STAR on heat pump water heaters: what distinguishes one from a tank or a tankless unit. ENERGY STAR now publishes a page per water heater type rather than one page for all of them.
9. Practice Practice
Minimum: one dated filter change, one booking and one temperature reading, which is the Start here result. Time: about an hour plus a phone call. Materials: a replacement filter, a flashlight, a marker for writing the date on the filter's edge, and the log.
- Pull the filter, read the size off the edge, and write it on the systems sheet. Buy three while you are at it.
- Write the date on the new filter's cardboard edge in marker as you fit it, so that next month's look answers its own question.
- Book the annual service, out of season, and write the two coverage sentences on the log before the visit.
- Read the water heater's setting and set it to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, recording what it was and what you left it at.
- Find your water's hardness from the utility report or a test, write it down, and set the flushing interval once with the service date calculator.
Two exercises. Walk the accessible duct runs in a basement, crawl space, attic or garage and mark every joint that is loose or taped with the wrong material, which turns ENERGY STAR's up-to-20-percent figure into a specific list rather than a general ambition. And sit in on the annual service: ask the technician to show you the readings they take, what they are looking at on the flue, and what MERV the blower will accept, which is a half hour that changes what every later conversation with a contractor sounds like.
10. Your house Your house
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Is the filter size on the systems sheet as three numbers, and is there a dated filter change on the log?
- Is the service booked or a date to book it written down, with the two coverage sentences recorded?
- Is the water heater's setting recorded, including what it was before you changed it?
- Do you know your water's hardness, and is the flushing interval set from it rather than guessed?
- Does every item in this chapter that you decided not to do yourself have a who and a date rather than being absent?
Worked example
The Okonkwos pass on all five, and the fifth is the one worth looking at. They did not test the relief valve. The sheet does not show that as a gap; it shows a row with "the plumber, at the next visit" in the who column. The difference between a decision and an omission is entirely in whether it is written down, and this is the chapter where that difference is worth the most, because several of its items are legitimately not yours.
Common mistakes
- Treating the monthly filter item as a change. It is a look, which is why it can be monthly.
- Booking the service in the first cold week. So is everybody, and you will get the appointment you get.
- Accepting a service visit that does not cover the flue. CPSC's sentence is specific, and asking for it in advance is how it happens.
- Fitting the highest MERV that fits the slot. EPA's recommendation ends with a limit, and the limit is the equipment's.
- Testing the relief valve without locating the shutoff first. The failure mode of that test is a valve that does not reseat, and the remedy is a shutoff you already know the location of.
- Using the half-the-replacement-cost rule. It has no published basis we found and it ignores how long each option lasts.
- Hunting for a central filter in a house that has none. Write "no central filter" once and stop looking.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not tell you the condition of your equipment, which is the technician's job and the reason the annual visit is in it. It does not tell you what MERV your blower will take, what your tankless unit's descaling interval is, or whether your system needs an expansion tank, all of which come from the equipment's own documentation or from a trade. The alarms, the chimney, the generator rules and the clearances are Alarms, vents and tests. And when the evaluation says replace, the comparison and the hiring are Choosing and keeping appliances and Hiring help.