Choosing and keeping appliances
Spending money well

Choosing a household appliance, and keeping the one you have

Everything sold today already meets a federal minimum, so efficient on a box means better than that minimum. Here is what the yellow label settles and what your own rate settles.

Start here Essentials

At minimum, record what you own, do the two maintenance items that have a published interval, and find your electricity rate. Test procedures, capacity measurement, the Most Efficient tier and the warranty interpretations are Go deeper.

  1. Write model and serial for each appliance on the systems sheet (registering and recalls).
  2. Clean the dryer's lint filter and look at the washing machine hoses (keeping the one you have).
  3. Find your electricity rate on a bill, in cents per kilowatt hour.
  4. For the appliance you are closest to replacing, run the running cost calculator on the one you have and one you are considering.

Minimum time: about 45 minutes. Done when: the systems sheet has a model and serial for every appliance, and one running cost comparison is written down.

1. Everything on the shelf already meets a minimum Understand

Start here because it reframes every appliance conversation you will have.

DOE runs an appliance and equipment standards program which, in its own description, is a Congressionally directed activity covering more than 70 products, representing about 90 percent of home energy use. A product in that scope cannot legally be sold new in the United States unless it meets the applicable minimum.

So when a box says efficient, what it means is better than that minimum. Not good in the abstract, not efficient compared to what you have, and not a claim about your bill. The whole question for a buyer is how much better, measured how, and what that is worth at the rate you actually pay.

Two consequences, and they run in opposite directions. A cheap new machine is not a wasteful machine in the way a cheap machine from 1998 was, which makes the bottom of the market less punishing than it used to be. And an old machine can be genuinely expensive to run: ENERGY STAR reports that on average an old refrigerator uses about 20 percent more energy than a model that has earned the ENERGY STAR, and that refrigerators over 15 years old could be costing about $95 a year to run.

Limits

This chapter makes no claim that a more efficient appliance pays for itself. It gives the published comparison figures with their baselines attached and the arithmetic to run them against your own electricity rate, and the answer comes out differently for different households in different places. What it does claim is narrower: that the numbers on the label are a test result rather than a bill, and that your rate is what turns one into the other.

2. The EnergyGuide label

The yellow label is not advertising. It is required by a federal regulation, 16 CFR part 305, and the regulation sets out what it carries and how the figures are determined.

What the rule governs, in its own terms:

  • Estimated annual energy consumption
  • Estimated annual operating cost
  • Energy efficiency rating
  • Water use rate
  • The range of comparability, defined as a group of models within a class that satisfy approximately the same consumer needs
  • The range of energy efficiency ratings and the range of estimated annual energy cost across that group

Two definitions in that rule are worth knowing because they govern what you are allowed to compare with what. A covered product is defined by listing product classes and by whatever else DOE classifies as covered. And the rule defines catalog to include material disseminated over the internet from which a consumer can order, which is why the label's content has to appear in online listings too. The rule also makes it unlawful for a manufacturer or private labeler knowingly to distribute a new covered product without a conforming label, hang tag or energy fact sheet.

What the label settles, and what it does not

The label gives youWhat it isWhat it is not
Estimated annual energy consumptionA test result, in kilowatt hours a year, from a defined procedureWhat your household will use
Estimated annual operating costThat consumption priced at a national energy figureYour bill, which uses your rate
The range across comparable modelsWhere this model sits among models meeting approximately the same needsA ranking across every model of every size

Use the kWh, not the dollars The kilowatt hour figure is the one that travels: it is the test result, and you can price it at your own rate. The dollar figure on the label is that same number priced at a national figure that is not yours. The running cost calculator takes the kWh, your rate, and the expected life, and gives you a lifetime running cost for two models side by side.

Your rate is on your electricity bill. Take the total charge divided by the kilowatt hours used, rather than the headline energy rate, because a bill usually has delivery and fixed charges in it too; the all-in figure is what an extra kilowatt hour actually costs you.

3. The two numbers that matter, by class

Every appliance class has its own measure, and knowing which two numbers to compare turns a showroom into a short list. These are ENERGY STAR's figures, and each one is reproduced here with its baseline attached, because they are measured against different baselines and a figure without its baseline is misleading.

Clothes washers

  • Integrated Modified Energy Factor (IMEF), where higher is better. It counts cycle energy, standby energy, the energy to heat the water, and the energy to run the dryer.
  • Integrated Water Factor (IWF), gallons of water per cubic foot of capacity, where lower is better.

Both are listed for every certified model in the ENERGY STAR Product Finder, which is what makes a comparison possible without a showroom. ENERGY STAR's headline figure: full-sized certified washers use 14 gallons of water per load, against 20 gallons for a standard machine. The baseline there is a standard machine.

Dishwashers

Capacity class first: ENERGY STAR defines standard-capacity models as holding more than eight place settings and six serving pieces, with compact models holding fewer, and notes that compact models may use more energy than standard models over time because of their smaller capacity. That is a real trap, because a compact machine looks like the efficient choice.

Its figures, each with its baseline:

  • A standard-size certified dishwasher costs about $50 per year to run.
  • It can save about 5,800 gallons of water over its lifetime. The baseline for that saving is over a lifetime.
  • A new certified dishwasher uses less than half as much energy as washing dishes by hand and saves 8,400 gallons of water each year. The baseline there is handwashing, and the figure is annual.

Why those two water figures differ 5,800 gallons over a lifetime and 8,400 gallons a year are not in conflict and they are not comparable either: they are measured against different baselines over different periods. Quoting one without the other, or either without its baseline, produces a sentence that sounds like a fact and is not one. This manual states the baseline every time.

Refrigerators

  • Certified refrigerators are about 9 percent more energy efficient than models that meet the federal minimum standard. The baseline is the federal minimum.
  • Recycling an old refrigerator and replacing it with a certified one can save about $150 over the 12-year lifetime of the product. The baseline is an old refrigerator, over twelve years.
  • On average an old refrigerator uses about 20 percent more energy than a model that has earned the ENERGY STAR, and refrigerators over 15 years old could be costing about $95 per year to run.
  • Fewer doors reduce air leakage, and door seals should be airtight and replaced if not.

Water heaters

Tank, tankless and heat pump water heaters are different machines with different running costs and different installation requirements. ENERGY STAR's water heaters page covers the certified types and what distinguishes them, and the running cost comparison is the same arithmetic as everything else in this chapter, with the caution that the running cost calculator handles electricity only. A gas appliance's running cost needs a gas rate and a different unit, and it is outside that box.

4. Repair or replace

The question arrives when something breaks, which is the worst moment to be thinking about arithmetic, so the arithmetic is simple on purpose.

Cost per remaining year of repairing, which is the repair quote divided by the extra years the repair is expected to buy, against cost per year of replacing, which is the replacement price divided by the replacement's expected life. The repair-or-replace calculator does both.

The number that decides it is the extra years, and that number comes from the technician. Ask for it in writing with the repair quote. A quote without it is a price, not a comparison.

Limits

The rule you will be told, that you should replace when a repair costs more than half a new one, has no published basis we found, and this manual does not use it. It compares two prices while ignoring how long each one lasts, which is the whole question. A $400 repair that buys eight years and a $900 machine that lasts twelve are a close call on cost per year and are not close on the half rule. The arithmetic also inherits the uncertainty of the technician's estimate, which is why the result says so.

Three things the arithmetic does not include, which you should decide separately and out loud:

  • Running cost. If the old machine is substantially less efficient, the running difference belongs in the comparison, and the running cost calculator gives it to you.
  • What a failure would cost. A washing machine on a second floor or above a finished ceiling is the sudden-and-wet case from What wears out and when, and that changes the answer.
  • Availability of parts. A repair that needs a part nobody stocks is not a repair with an uncertain cost; it is not a repair.

5. Keeping the one you have

The published maintenance for household appliances is short, which is itself worth knowing. University of Georgia Extension's home maintenance checklist carries most of it:

  • Clean the washing machine's water inlet filters and check the hoses, replacing them if they are leaking.
  • Clean the dryer's lint filter after every use.
  • Clean a dehumidifier's coils and filter.
  • Check water purification and water softener filters.
  • Inspect the caulking and grout around toilets, tubs, showers and sinks.

And from ENERGY STAR: check that a refrigerator's door seals are airtight and replace them if not. A simple check is to close the door on a piece of paper; if it pulls out with no resistance, the seal is not sealing there.

The washing machine hoses, specifically

This one earns its own paragraph because the published item is a check and the consequence is tier 1. A supply hose under constant household water pressure that fails while nobody is home runs until somebody comes home. The check is to look at the hoses for bulges, cracks or rust at the crimp, and the inexpensive change is braided stainless hoses and shutoffs that actually turn. What wears out and when puts this in the category of cheap parts that change what a failure costs rather than maintenance in the usual sense.

What is not here

A gap, named There is a great deal of appliance maintenance advice in circulation (coil cleaning intervals, cleaning cycles, descaling schedules) for which we did not find an agency or extension publication giving an interval. The maker's manual is the authority for those, and this manual does not invent a number to fill the space. Where your manual gives an interval, put it on your calendar with the maker named as the source, which is exactly how the published intervals are recorded.

6. Registering, warranties and recalls

Model and serial, on a sheet

Everything in this section starts from having the numbers. Model and serial, on the systems sheet, for every appliance. It is what a recall search asks for, what a warranty claim asks for, what a parts order asks for, and what an insurance claim asks for. The plates are usually inside a door frame, behind a drawer panel, on the back, or on a side wall inside a refrigerator; Walk your house has the locations.

Recalls

CPSC publishes recalls and product safety warnings in a searchable database, filterable by hazard and by product category, with a CSV export. SaferProducts.gov is the companion site where the public can file and read complaints about consumer products, and where you can search before you buy.

Two habits: search your major appliances once, when you first write the numbers down, and search a model before you buy it. Neither takes long, and the second one is the better of the two.

Warranties, and the odd line that matters to a homeowner

Written warranties on consumer products are governed by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and the FTC's interpretations at 16 CFR part 700, which cover what a written warranty is, who is actually making one, the full and limited designations, and the duty to install under a full warranty.

The part that matters most to a householder is in section 700.1(e), and it draws a line people trip over. Products that go into the construction of a dwelling are consumer products when sold over the counter, by hardware and building supply retailers, and also when a consumer contracts for them in connection with the improvement, repair or modification of a home, with the text naming paneling, dropped ceilings, siding, roofing, storm windows and remodeling. But where such products are integrated into the structure of a dwelling at the time of sale they are not consumer products, because they cannot practically be distinguished from realty. So beams, wallboard, wiring, plumbing, windows and roofing sold as part of real estate under a written warranty fall outside the Act.

Ask the authority Which is why a builder's warranty on a new house and an appliance warranty are different animals with different law behind them, and why a question about what a particular warranty covers is a question for the warranty document, and if it is disputed, for a lawyer or your state consumer protection office. This manual gives no legal advice.

One practical point: registering a product is not what creates the warranty. It is a convenience for the manufacturer and sometimes for recall notification. Keep the receipt and the model and serial, which are what a claim actually rests on.

Go deeper

Why a test procedure is not a household

Every figure on an EnergyGuide label comes from a defined test procedure: a specified load, a specified cycle, a specified ambient condition. That is what makes two models comparable, and it is also why the label says estimate. Your household runs different loads at different frequencies with different water temperatures, and the gap between the test and your use is not an error in the label. Use the label to rank models and your own rate to price them, and treat the absolute figure as approximately right rather than as a prediction.

The ENERGY STAR Most Efficient tier

Within certified products, ENERGY STAR designates a Most Efficient tier each year for models at the top of the range. It is a narrower list and the criteria change annually, which is worth knowing when comparing a review written two years ago with a product on a shelf today.

Capacity, and what a cubic foot means in practice

Capacity for washers and refrigerators is a measured internal volume, and more of it is not free: a larger drum uses more water and energy per cycle even while using less per unit of capacity, which is the mechanism behind ENERGY STAR's note that a compact dishwasher may use more energy than a standard one over time. The useful question is not which is bigger but which matches how much you actually wash in one go.

Dishwasher noise

Noise is usually quoted in decibels and it is one of the most-compared numbers in dishwasher marketing. We did not find a publisher whose figures we could cite for how those ratings are produced or compared, so this manual gives no guidance on them beyond noting that the number exists and that we could not source it.

The baselines, side by side

Collecting section 3's figures with their baselines in one place, because this is the comparison that gets mangled most often. Washers: 14 gallons per load against 20 for a standard machine. Dishwashers: about $50 a year to run; about 5,800 gallons saved over a lifetime; and, against handwashing rather than against another machine, less than half the energy and 8,400 gallons a year. Refrigerators: about 9 percent more efficient than the federal minimum; about $150 saved over a 12-year lifetime against an old refrigerator; about 20 percent more energy used by an old one on average; and about $95 a year for one over 15 years old. Four different baselines across three product classes, which is why a sentence that stacks them together is not saying anything.

Service contracts and home warranties

These come up at the point of sale and they are not a product warranty. FTC's position is that home warranties are really service contracts, that unlike builder warranties or warranties included with products they cost extra, and that they may duplicate coverage you already have. Hiring help works through FTC's four questions in full.

Full and limited, and the duty to install

The Magnuson-Moss interpretations govern how a warranty is designated as full or limited, who is treated as actually making it, and the duty to install under a full warranty. Those are definitional questions rather than practical ones for most households, and the place to read them is 16 CFR part 700 itself, which is short.

7. See it See it

Fictional example

Marisol Reyes, the 1996 two-story in Austin, bought in March. Her refrigerator came with the house and its data plate is readable inside, above the crisper drawers. Her washer and dryer she brought with her and bought new four years ago.

Known. Model and serial for all three, now on the systems sheet. Her electricity rate, taken from a bill as the total charge divided by the kilowatt hours, which came out higher than the headline energy rate because of delivery and fixed charges. The refrigerator's data plate carries a date that makes it about 16 years old.

Assumed, and it is Marisol's: that the refrigerator is drawing roughly what ENERGY STAR's figure for an old unit suggests. ENERGY STAR reports that refrigerators over 15 years old could be costing about $95 per year to run, and that on average an old refrigerator uses about 20 percent more energy than a certified model. Those are national figures against stated baselines, not measurements of her machine. What would settle it is a plug-in energy meter on the refrigerator's outlet for a week, which costs less than a month of the difference.

Still open, with who settles each: whether the door seals are failing, which she can test with a piece of paper around the whole perimeter; whether a replacement would fit the opening, which a tape measure settles; and whether the unit is subject to any recall, which a search of CPSC's recall database settles from the model number she now has.

What she ran. The running cost calculator, with the published annual kilowatt hour figure for a certified model of the size she would buy, her own rate, a 12-year life, and a purchase price from a local listing. For the existing unit she used an estimate rather than a label figure, because a 16-year-old label is not in her kitchen, and she wrote on the sheet that the old machine's figure was estimated.

Her conclusion, with its uncertainty intact. Under those assumptions the replacement looks worth doing before the old unit fails rather than after, and the thing that would settle it is a week with a plug-in meter, which she has ordered. She did not buy anything that day, and the sentence she wrote is a decision about what evidence to collect rather than a decision about a refrigerator.

8. Practice Practice

Minimum: the model and serial numbers, the two maintenance items and one running cost comparison, which is the Start here result. Time: about 45 minutes. Materials: a flashlight, a phone camera, an electricity bill, a piece of paper for the door seal test, and the systems sheet.

  1. Photograph and transcribe every appliance's data plate. Inside door frames, behind drawer panels, on backs, and above crisper drawers.
  2. Do the paper test around the whole refrigerator door seal, not just at one point, and note where it pulls out freely.
  3. Look at the washing machine hoses for bulges, cracks and rust at the crimp, and check that its shutoff valves actually turn.
  4. Work out your all-in electricity rate from the bill: total charge divided by kilowatt hours.
  5. Run one comparison in the running cost calculator and write the result, with its assumptions, on the sheet.
Go deeper

Two exercises. Put a plug-in energy meter on your oldest large appliance for a week and compare the measured figure with the published estimate for its class, which is the only way to replace an assumption with a measurement here. And search every model number you now have in CPSC's recall database, which takes about ten minutes once the numbers are on a sheet and is the single clearest return on having written them down.

9. Your house Your house

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does every appliance have a model and serial on the systems sheet, rather than in a drawer or a photo roll?
  • Is your electricity rate the all-in figure from a bill rather than the headline energy rate?
  • Does every published figure you wrote down carry its baseline?
  • If you ran a comparison, does it say which numbers were estimates and which came from labels?
  • Have you searched your models against CPSC's recall database at least once?

Worked example

Marisol passes on all five. The one worth pointing at is the fourth: her comparison marks the old refrigerator's consumption as estimated rather than quoting it as a fact, and her written conclusion names the plug-in meter as the thing that would settle it. That is the difference between a decision that can be revisited and one that cannot, because in six months nobody remembers which figure was a label and which was a guess.

Common mistakes

  • Using the label's dollar figure. It is the kilowatt hour figure priced at a national rate, not at yours.
  • Using the headline energy rate from the bill. Delivery and fixed charges mean the all-in figure is what an extra kilowatt hour costs you.
  • Quoting an ENERGY STAR figure without its baseline. Against the federal minimum, against an old unit and against handwashing are three different claims.
  • Buying compact to save energy. ENERGY STAR notes that a compact dishwasher may use more energy than a standard one over time.
  • Using the half-the-replacement-cost rule. It has no published basis we found and it ignores how long each option lasts.
  • Thinking registration creates the warranty. The receipt, the model and the serial are what a claim rests on.
  • Leaving the washing machine hoses unchecked. It is a tier 1 consequence behind a tier 3 object.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not tell you which appliance to buy, and it does not claim that an efficient one pays for itself. It gives you the figures with their baselines and the arithmetic to run them at your own rate. It cannot tell you how long a particular machine will last, which is What wears out and when and its caveats. It cannot tell you your maker's maintenance intervals, which are in the manual. And whether a service contract is worth buying, which is the question the salesperson will ask you at the counter, is Hiring help.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does this chapter say to use the label's kilowatt hour figure rather than its dollar figure?
Because the dollar figure is the same test result priced at a national energy figure that is not your rate. The kilowatt hours travel: price them at your own all-in rate and you get a number about your household. The label itself describes the figure as an estimate from a test procedure.
ENERGY STAR says a certified dishwasher saves about 5,800 gallons over its lifetime and 8,400 gallons each year. Are those in conflict?
No, and they are not comparable either. The 5,800 figure is a lifetime saving against another machine; the 8,400 figure is an annual saving against washing dishes by hand. Different baselines over different periods. Either figure quoted without its baseline sounds like a fact and is not one.
A technician quotes $380 to repair a washing machine. What do you need before you can compare it with buying a new one?
The number of extra years the repair is expected to buy, in writing. Without it you have two prices rather than a comparison. Then cost per remaining year on each side, plus the running cost difference and, if the machine is above a finished ceiling, what a failure would cost.
(Go deeper) Why is a new window bought at a building supply store a consumer product, while the same window in a new house is not?
16 CFR 700.1(e) draws the line at integration into the structure at the time of sale. Sold over the counter, or contracted for in connection with improving or repairing a home, it is a consumer product under the Act. Integrated into the dwelling at the time of sale, it cannot practically be distinguished from realty and falls outside it. That is why a builder's warranty and an appliance warranty have different law behind them.
Your 16 year old refrigerator still works. A salesperson tells you a new one will pay for itself in three years. What do you do with that claim?
This is the method. ENERGY STAR's figures are against stated baselines (about 9 percent better than the federal minimum, about $150 over a 12-year lifetime against an old unit, about $95 a year for one over 15 years old), and a payback claim needs your rate and a measurement or an estimate of what the old machine actually draws. A plug-in meter for a week turns the whole question into arithmetic.
ENERGY STAR's figures are real and they are national estimates against particular baselines, which is not the same as a payback period for your kitchen at your rate. A salesperson's three years is a claim with inputs you have not seen.
A defensible instinct and not a rule. An old refrigerator is one of the few appliances with published figures suggesting real running cost differences, and it is also the one most likely to fail quietly rather than dramatically. Measure it rather than deciding on principle either way.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.